return to table of content

Lynn Conway Has Died

mattecypress
10 replies
56m

Not to be mistaken with John Conway, known for Conway’s game of life.

wincy
8 replies
49m

Honestly considering Lynn Conway’s Wikipedia profile mentions being a transgender activist and not knowing much about either of them, I thought maybe I’d just missed that John Conway had transitioned at some point, and had now died.

someperson
6 replies
26m

It really doesn't help that the Wikipedia page doesn't currently appear to state the former name anywhere, like it often does for other people (like celebrities) who legally change their names at some point in their lives.

amysox
3 replies
23m

This is in keeping with their gender identity guidelines.

Former, pre-transition names may only be included if the person was notable while using the name; outside of the main biographical article, such names should only appear once, in a footnote or parentheses.
mlyle
2 replies
15m

if the person was notable while using the name

ACS was a notable project and her involvement in it, pre-transition, was notable.

skyyler
0 replies
2m

A notable project where her work was confidential.

Her deadname did not have achievements publicly associated with it in the way wikipedia requires.

LukasMathis
0 replies
5m

I guess the point is that she, herself, was not notable at that point, since her work was not widely and publicly known. Otherwise we'd already know her pre-transition name.

samatman
0 replies
17m

There's a whole set of criteria for when Wikipedia will and will not list former names for people who transition, which boils down to whether they achieved notability under the old name. Which Lynn did not.

There's a conversation to be had about whether the decisions Wikipedia has made about prior names and consistent use of pronouns in the biography of trans persons is the correct one for an encyclopedia. But this is definitely not the place or time to have that conversation.

kragen
0 replies
23m

she had to go to significant pains to conceal her former name because it revealed her former sex, and trans women are at significant risk of getting lynched, even more so 50 years ago

dexwiz
0 replies
46m

John Conway died over 4 years ago.

reducesuffering
0 replies
50m

Nor the Melvin Conway, of Conway's law.

barbazoo
3 replies
45m

Thanks for sharing!

In case anyone knows, what's the best way to get this to be readable on an e-reader? Haven't found a PDF yet, probably exporting into a PDF is the easiest since it's only a couple dozen pages maybe?!

lye
1 replies
25m

Save as HTML with images and run through Calibre:

  $ ebook-convert index.html book.epub
Here are the files if you trust a rando on the internet. Since they're just ZIP archives, you can unpack and inspect both to make sure there's no JS there. .mobi looks fine on my Kindle.

https://0x0.st/Xc8M.epub

https://0x0.st/Xc8B.mobi

barbazoo
0 replies
15m

if you trust a rando on the internet

Why did you say that, now I have to check the files :)

Thank you

spencerchubb
0 replies
40m

Incredible

"The fact that I started a new career all over again, at the bottom of the ladder, after being fired by IBM and rejected by family and friends . . . may also give hope to others trapped in similar situations."

meifun
0 replies
29m

Thank you for sharing!! Fascinating and really helpful to those of us who are undergoing our own gender transitions!

minedwiz
7 replies
57m

If this is verified, I think a black band is 100% warranted. As I understand it, she was a real innovator in VLSI, which I think we all agree is somewhat important :)

EDIT: GG, the black band appeared as I sent this

DonHopkins
3 replies
36m

Absolutely. I was friends with her on Facebook and enjoyed reading her many postings. She has a huge network of fans and followers whose lives she's touched.

Jonathan Payne, an old co-worker and former friend of mine who I worked with at Sun on NeWS, and who also worked on Java, on two different recent occasions dropped in on my Facebook page uninvited in the middle of friendly discussions with my friends about trans and LGBTQ issues, and spouted unexpected hateful transphobic bigotry, and parroted J K Rowlings unhinged hate speech (that even was too much for Elon Musk).

I was mortified and embarrassed that Lynn Conway might see what Jonathan wrote in public for all to see on my own Facebook page, and shocked that he was so obsessed with letting everyone know about his own bigotry. She's had to deal with so much abuse and hatred in her life, and selflessly helped so many people, that she and my many other LGBTQ friends absolutely didn't deserve to read the kind of vile stuff that Jonathan wrote, floating across her Facebook feed like a turd in the swimming pool, with my name associated with it.

It was really disappointing that Jonathan Payne, someone I've known for 35 years, who professes to be "progressive", not only fell for but also spewed in public the same horrible lies that the right wing bigots have been telling about gay people for ages, and still tell about trans people now that gay people have finally been begrudgingly granted the right to marry. They cast themselves as the victim because they can't get away with being openly anti-gay any more, so they take it out even more mendaciously on trans people, using the exact same hate speech and lies about "groomers" and moral panic about "not knowing what it means to be a woman". Disgraceful.

ljsprague: What he said was way too vile to repeat here, but contact me by email and I will send you a screen snapshot. Obviously he (and J K Rowling and Elon Musk) are pathologically fixated and obsessed to the point of mental illness to be that aggressive about attacking people out of the blue in public who they don't even know and who have absolutely no negative effect on their lives. In the case of Lynn, she's had a huge positive effect on all of our lives, and I'd expect a programmer like Jonathan to be aware of that. But all people deserve respect simply for being human, they shouldn't have to invent both superscalar architecture and VLSI design in one lifetime just to be treated politely.

minedwiz
0 replies
30m

Quite disappointing to hear; I know the feeling on discovering unfortunate things coworkers believe :(. I can scarcely imagine the feeling of seeing real progress happen on trans acceptance, only to then see a blowback coming, right at the end of your life. Glad she will be remembered positively.

ljsprague
0 replies
31m

What did Jonathan Payne say?

brcmthrowaway
0 replies
0m

Jonathan Payne can sue you for defamation for this, you know?

metalliqaz
1 replies
44m

omg is that what that is?

all this time I thought the CSS was screwed up on my browser. I had assumed it all my anti-ad/privacy plugins.

minedwiz
0 replies
32m

Yep, loss of a prominent HN-relevant person.

adrian_b
0 replies
13m

While her contributions to the VLSI design methodologies are the best known and the most influential, that is because at that time she worked in academia, in plain sight.

She had another extremely important contribution much earlier, when working at IBM, at the Advanced Computer System project.

She invented the first methods that could be used for designing a CPU that can initiate multiple instructions in the same clock cycle and also out of order in comparison with the program. Such a CPU will be named only 2 decades later as a superscalar CPU (also inside IBM and by people familiar with the old ACS project). (The earlier CDC 6600 could initiate only 1 instruction per clock cycle, in program order, even if after initiation it could execute the instructions concurrently and complete them out-of-order, depending on the availability of execution units.)

Her work on superscalar CPUs did not become known until much later, because it was written in confidential internal reports about the ACS project, which was canceled, unlike the later and much less comprehensive work of Tomasulo, which was published in a journal and which was used in a commercial product, so it became the reference on out-of-order execution in the open literature, for several decades.

At the time when she worked at IBM, her legal gender was still male, and when she announced her intention of gender change, she was fired by IBM, which is likely to have contributed to the obscurity that covered her ACS work at IBM.

Her "Dynamic Instruction Scheduling" report from 1966 is mandatory reading for anyone who is interested about the evolution of the superscalar and out-of-order CPUs.

https://ai.eecs.umich.edu/people/conway/ACS/Archive/ACSarchi...

meifun
2 replies
27m

Thank you for the inspiration as I continue my gender transition. I appreciate your struggles and dedication to living a life that was "for you" and not for anyone else. RIP.

startupsfail
1 replies
6m

Wikipedia actually says “She figures out a way so that everybody wins”. Hard to tell. Being a child in a family in which dad suddenly is no longer there and “struggling with life in a male role” doesn’t sound like a good place to be. Anyway, RIP.

bo0tzz
0 replies
4m

What are you trying to say?

1024core
2 replies
15m

Why does the Wiki page say "citation needed" for calling her a "computer scientist, electrical engineer"?

waterhouse
0 replies
2m

If you were looking at the same revision I saw, the "citation needed" was on the word "was", and on mouseover said "Please add credible news of death".

amin
0 replies
10m

The beauty of Wikipedia is that you (yes you) can add a citation in which she’s called a “computer scientist, electrical engineer”, and then remove the [citation needed]. I hope you give it a try. I’ve been editing Wikipedia for 6 years now.

electriclove
1 replies
35m

Why does Wikipedia not list the first spouse or children?

amysox
0 replies
26m

No confirmed sources. This was discussed on the talk page.

DonHopkins
1 replies
1h5m

Lynn Conway, co-author along with Carver Mead of "the textbook" on VLSI design, "Introduction to VLSI Systems", created and taught this historic VLSI Design Course in 1978, which was the first time students designed and fabricated their own integrated circuits:

"Importantly, these weren’t just any designs, for many pushed the envelope of system architecture. Jim Clark, for instance, prototyped the Geometry Engine and went on to launch Silicon Graphics Incorporated based on that work (see Fig. 16). Guy Steele, Gerry Sussman, Jack Holloway and Alan Bell created the follow-on ‘Scheme’ (a dialect of LISP) microprocessor, another stunning design."

Many more links and beautiful illustrations of her student's VLSI designs:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31758139

Also, Jim Clark (SGI, Netscape) was one of Lynn Conway's students, and she taught him how to make his first prototype "Geometry Engine"!

http://ai.eecs.umich.edu/people/conway/VLSI/MPCAdv/MPCAdv.ht...

Just 29 days after the design deadline time at the end of the courses, packaged custom wire-bonded chips were shipped back to all the MPC79 designers. Many of these worked as planned, and the overall activity was a great success. I'll now project photos of several interesting MPC79 projects. First is one of the multiproject chips produced by students and faculty researchers at Stanford University (Fig. 5). Among these is the first prototype of the "Geometry Engine", a high performance computer graphics image-generation system, designed by Jim Clark. That project has since evolved into a very interesting architectural exploration and development project.[9]

Figure 5. Photo of MPC79 Die-Type BK (containing projects from Stanford University):

http://ai.eecs.umich.edu/people/conway/VLSI/MPCAdv/SU-BK1.jp...

[...]

The text itself passed through drafts, became a manuscript, went on to become a published text. Design environments evolved from primitive CIF editors and CIF plotting software on to include all sorts of advanced symbolic layout generators and analysis aids. Some new architectural paradigms have begun to similarly evolve. An example is the series of designs produced by the OM project here at Caltech. At MIT there has been the work on evolving the LISP microprocessors [3,10]. At Stanford, Jim Clark's prototype geometry engine, done as a project for MPC79, has gone on to become the basis of a very powerful graphics processing system architecture [9], involving a later iteration of his prototype plus new work by Marc Hannah on an image memory processor [20].

[...]

For example, the early circuit extractor work done by Clark Baker [16] at MIT became very widely known because Clark made access to the program available to a number of people in the network community. From Clark's viewpoint, this further tested the program and validated the concepts involved. But Clark's use of the network made many, many people aware of what the concept was about. The extractor proved so useful that knowledge about it propagated very rapidly through the community. (Another factor may have been the clever and often bizarre error-messages that Clark's program generated when it found an error in a user's design!)

9. J. Clark, "A VLSI Geometry Processor for Graphics", Computer, Vol. 13, No. 7, July, 1980.

fwip
0 replies
59m

This book was so good that I bought myself a new copy years after leaving college - the only textbook I've done that for.

tibbydudeza
0 replies
24m

I hope that at some point she could reconnect with her kids from her prior marriage.

nxobject
0 replies
51m

A woman of incredible courage - to be able to rebuild her career after being kicked out of IBM despite her achievements, is inspirational. And, given how even the implementation of superscalar processors confuses me, smarter than I’ll ever be for understanding that AND chip fabbing at the same time, one of humanity’s finest technical achievements.

kstrauser
0 replies
46m

What an absolute genius. RIP, Lynn.

dekhn
0 replies
40m

I met her totally at random at a bio conference in hawaii- I sat down next to her at a bar and we started chatting. I asked what she did and she said VLSI- something I knew nothing about (I was a biologist). She was curious about biology and wanted to learn about how she could help. I looked her name up later and learned she really did work in VLSI :)

betimsl
0 replies
38m

Great loss for our community.

Upvoter33
0 replies
34m

Great prof. Changed my entire career arc. RIP.

SnooSux
0 replies
1m

She spoke at my commencement a few years back. Her story is an interesting one

SnooSux
0 replies
3m

She spoke at my commencement a few years back, I was

KennyBlanken
0 replies
24m

Although she had hoped to be allowed to transition on the job, IBM fired Conway in 1968 after she revealed her intention to transition.[19] IBM apologized for this in 2020.

Given that in 2012 there was an entire IEEE magazine issue dedicated to her career and contributions to the field which really brought awareness of all her contributions...it's disappointing it took IBM so long to apologize, especially given they outed her circa ~2000.

DonHopkins
0 replies
1h6m

Lynn Conway co-wrote "the book" on VLSI design, "Introduction to VLSI Systems", created and taught this historic VLSI Design Course in 1978, which was the first time students designed and fabricated their own integrated circuits, including James Clark (SGI) who made the Geometry Engine, and Guy L Steel (MIT) who made the Scheme Microprocessor.

She invented superscalar architecture at IBM, just to be fired in 1968 after she revealed her intention to transition, then 52 years later IBM formally apologized to her in 2020. She successfully rebooted her life, invented and taught VLSI design to industry pioneers who founded many successful companies based on the design methodology she invented, wrote the book on, and personally taught to them, and then she became a trans activist who helped many people transition, find each other, and avoid suicide, fight abuse and bigotry, and find acceptance, by telling her story and building an online community.

Lynn Conway receives 2009 IEEE Computer Society Computer Pioneer Award:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4Txvjia3p0