Hi yall, founder of Daylight here.
Happy to answer any questions you have. Long time lurker, so this is pretty cool to finally take part :)
I made this because I wanted the eye-strain free and minimalist qualities of my kindle/Eink applied to so much more of what I do on a computer.
Lack of speed and ghosting felt like it made traditional Eink impossible to do most computing tasks. So we focused on making the most Paperlike epaper display that has no ghosting and high refresh rate - 60 to 120fps. We started working on this in 2018.
We developed our own custom epaper display tech we call LivePaper. We focused on solving the tradeoffs RLCDs traditionally have - around reflectance %, metallic-look / not Paperlike enough, viewing angle, white state, rainbow mura, parallax, resolution, size, lack of quality backlight, etc.
First proof of concept in late 2021, and then it took us 2.5 years to get it into production.
And we built a whole android tablet around it.
It’s essentially our attempt at making a remarkable tablet on steroids / kindle on steroids. Definitely some trade offs, but on the whole we think it’s worth it. (& on twitter a bunch of early customers seem to think so too)
Note: it’s 60fps epaper, not off the shelf Eink. We spent years developing what we think is the best epaper display in the world and it’s exclusively manufactured by our display factory in Japan.
There’s still many cases where traditional Eink is going to be better (bistability, viewing angle, white state color, etc), but we feel for more general purpose computers you can code on and do google docs on and do fast multitouch amongst a thousand other things, the speed and lack of ghosting totally makes it worth it.
Think of it as a Godzilla sized pebble watch with a decade of improvement
Or think of it as a gameboy advanced, advanced
Adding an additional comment here for a little extra visibility. I would absolutely love, like really love, a USB-C portrait monitor version of this. If I could just plug this in to my existing laptop and use it for reading specs, technical docs, …etc that would be amazing.
Android tablet is a tough sell for my employer due to compliance, security, and such. So buying one of those for work use would take like a year minimum gathering all the necessary approvals and likely would still get denied by someone. But, a dumb monitor with no real OS I can expense that without approval. just a heads up to my boss really to say I am buying this and here is why.
I know you are a small company so have to pick your battles. But, maybe something to consider down the road.
EDIt: forgot to say, congrats on the launch. Looks like a great product.
I second this. I really enjoy reading and writing on an Onyx e-ink tab, and I like the full Android functionality, but I can never use it for work or even for personal email logins, because I don't trust their custom Android build.
I would be somewhat more inclined to trust Daylight than Onyx, but any custom OS is too potentially vulnerable to backdoors for my use cases.
Something like this that you could load your own Linux flavor onto, or simply this tech as a monitor / drawing pad, I would drop the money in a heartbeat.
Is there such a thing as a tablet that accepts video input? In other words, use it as a tablet, then connect a mini hdmi or whatever and it turns into a monitor. Disconnect, and it's a tablet again.
The minisforum v3 is a windows tablet that can also act like a monitor - https://www.minisforum.com/page/v3/index.html?lang=en
And, I think the lenovo yoga tab 13 is an Android tablet with a similar feature: https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/tablets/android-tablets/lenov...
The recently released Minisforum V3 AMD tablet has this:
https://store.minisforum.com/products/minisforum-v3
There are certainly some e-ink devices that are able to do this, the TechnologyConnections fellow did a couple of videos that cover it, amongst other things: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7NfX0vlCa4k#t=15m50 & https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D38dcArwCNc
Though he is using a Boox product and I'm wary of them over the GPL violation thing: as well as the general “they'd piss & moan and send the lawyers round if someone took their stuff and used it unlicensed” hypocrisy, the paranoid cynic in me thinks there is something they want to hide in their customisations (hooks for calling home or some such).
Also, those clips are a few years old now so some of the problems he was having may have been ironed out in newer devices & software updates.
Another option is running a VMC client on any tablet that isn't walled off so that you can't: there are a number of VNC servers that create a hidden virtual screen and mirror that so the connecting client because the extra screen.
I use a hdmi capture dongle with iPad to turn it into a monitor. Not quite what you want, but as an option.
As long as the bootloader isn't locked, porting mainline Linux shouldn't be as bad as with E-ink devices. Here's a Ubuntu Touch port to another Helios G99 device [1]; I really hope the RLCD doesn't require host driver support.
[1]: https://devices.ubuntu-touch.io/device/vidofnir/
You need USB-C DisplayPort (DP Alt Mode). Unfortunately it's not a software limitation oftentimes, most of the times it's a hardware design limitation. I guess Onyx figured that they can have two different product lines and milk both, as opposed to what they used to have, which was an HDMI port on the higher end models.
Best would be DP alt mode. However software to send video over regular USB data lines is fairly common and reportedly works okay so long as you have drivers (which generally are not supported to the next Windows release) and are not trying something too heavy - not good enough for games but often good enough for the office type work the OP is asking for.
https://onyxboox.com/boox_mirapro
Good, but definitely not 60fps or ghosting free. Source: using one right now.
Did you consider PineNote?
Note tha its production was put to stop (last year IIRC) with reserve to possibly start it again. AFAICT market reception was lukewarm at best and it was not financially viable.
I would have loved one, but I guess leaving the development of a proper OS to the community is not going to land mass adoption.
Average Joe needs a device to buy and use, not to buy and tinker with.
Same here. I use degoogled Onyx Boox for notes, reading books, sheet music, sketching... Barely connect to internet, beacuse I don't trust their OS and apps. Apps are actually quite good (NeoReader).
I would love it just as a screen for things like Slack or Discord as I'm on the move a lot :D
How much customization is needed for a device like this?
Drivers?
I'd think most of it would come down to a custom launcher. Though I guess they also modify the UI?
There are e-ink monitors, e.g. [1]. I’ve never used one so I can’t speak to how well they work.
[1] https://shop.dasung.com/products/dasung-25-3-curved-e-ink-mo...
When plugged in to a computer, it would be cool if it reverts to being a smart display with touch screen. It could still charge and transfer files too maybe? I don’t know enough about USB-C, but I really wish devices could do dual function like this.
When venturing into the file transfer territory, a lot of employers are going to veto the device over security concerns. Just like they wouldn’t want employees plugging in random USB drives found on the street.
Or USB drives period. My former employer didn't allow cell phones or really any device that could connect things from the outside. We had the Internet, but it all had to go through their own managed pipes.
Totally fine to bring in a monitor though. Not sure if that would still be true today, given the connectivity of things. I bet you could still bring in a monitor, but you'd risk needing to prove that there was no way it could do anything other than be a monitor.
I think there would be better luck with a dedicated monitor port (HDMI, DisplayPort, DVI, VGA), rather than a USB-C monitor, depending on how hard things are locked down.
It's feasible: a couple of Lenovo Yoga Tabs do this* running Android 13+ until plugged in by an HDMI out (which I believe works with an adapter to USB-C). Ex: https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/tablets/android-tablets/lenov... *(Not touch-enabled in display mode, I believe.)
I have a Yoga Tab 13 (the more interesting sibling of the P-series) I regularly use as a standalone tablet and external laptop monitor - usually lives in the same bag. It's been perfectly seamless for me whether using a PC or a smartphone (surprisingly so). (I believe it shipped w Android 12.)
Of course, it's not epaper - but it is technically feasible.
Can you run Linux on this yoga tab?
The Minisforum V3 is a tablet that can also be used as a monitor via USB-C, so definitely possible. I wish more tablets would work that way.
There's the spacedesk app that can do this with Android and Windows. Works fairly well.
USB-C iPads can act as monitors via HDMI adapter + various apps.
From a compliance POV what's an acceptable alternative? Would some unix variant be any more palatable?
In some industries, anything that “computes” or has a data connection is strictly regulated. If data can move in or out, it needs to be verified.
So, if you want to avoid those validation steps, it would need to be a dumb device without an OS. Like the parent said - just a monitor.
I agree with the sentiment, but it is harder and harder to find truly "dumb" devices anymore. USB has a complicated (and vulnerable) firmware stack. Monitors have hackable on screen display controllers. Unless you want to go back to VGA... Just saying...
https://github.com/redballoonshenanigans/monitordarkly
In this context, I think of two things: hackable spying and data exfiltration.
If a device runs processes that can be hacked so that it can report on your activities. Capturing the display or keyboard input would be examples. This generally requires an active network connection, but not always. Because this device runs a version of Android, it’s potentially hackable (I’m not saying it isn’t secure, just that it would have to be validated).
Second, if a device can store or transfer data, it would be possible to send confidential documents out the door without knowing about it. Because this has on-board storage (and is small), it has this issue too.
A monitor, even if its OSD/firmware was hacked, is much less likely to be able to do either of these things.
There are industries that have real concerns about data privacy and security. In these cases, the dumber a device, generally the better.
I would think the main thing would be no network hardware and ideally no network stack. After that, a minimum of local storage- nothing persistent outside of firmware, and certainly nothing that would provide any type of file system visible to the host computer.
What about a firmware flash that nukes the Android part and makes it behave as a display, which hopefully you can flash back to your OS if policy or usecase changes?
I was about to write the same comment but you expressed it much better. I would also be happy if it could be both an android tablet but have a monitor mode where it just becomes a monitor.
You can use VNC to make an android tablet into a 2nd monitor. The latency isnt good enough for playing games or anything but for web pages and documents it works great.
I've tried that before but the latency bothers me a lot even when typing, etc.
I've recently been using a piece of software called RustDesk, which so far feels pretty performant, better than VNC, RDP, TeamViewer, RealVNC etc.: https://rustdesk.com/
You can host a relay inside of a Docker container if you need it as well and it even supports AV1. There's also password auth for each device and permission control.
They have a mobile app too, though I haven't used it as much as the desktop variety, might be worth a shot.
Plus one on this. Would be amazing if there was a display mode possible or just a variant with a usb to edp board inside without the android tablet bits / battery (even if it meant losing the wacom digitizer in the process)
Why not just buy a Mira Pro? https://onyxboox.com/boox_mirapro
There is also a transflective lcd portable monitor: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/radiant-world-s-first-tra...
Video from MyDeepGuide: https://youtube.com/watch?v=NXLwc0eJZsw
Onyx is a GPL violator unfortunately: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23735962
Thanks for the link. I am actually just starting my research into that one and options from Dasung.
This is one of those things that I didn’t know I needed/wanted until this HN post. But, I get bad headaches from eye strain and a have a heavy text based workflow so definitely in that target market.
Because it allows Android apps, might there be some screen sharing utility that would allow it to be used as a 2nd monitor?
Maybe. But for some employers, it's only their devices. Which would still mean going through the process above.
spacedesk (sadly Windows only)
I can only imagine how much tougher a Windows sell would be to your employer.
Their employer likely has absolute control over their Windows install. My personal Windows laptop isn't allowed on the corporate network either.
(adding my voice) I would buy a dumb monitor of this without thinking. Name your price Daylight team.
shut up and take my money.
Does it support a separate work profile that can be managed by the Ivanti Mobile@Work app?
If you can make it bigger for use as a regular monitor, I'd pay good money for it.
This. Absolutely. A second paper like display would be perfect.
I would also buy without thinking a mini monitor, but no so much a tablet. Please think about launching it.
If I could use this as an external monitor plugged into my MacBook I would have bought one on the spot.
Would this not be better solved with some remote desktop protocol (RDP or VNC) than with USB? Then you can use it with wifi and just walk off with the device.
Oh hell yeah!
Or to my existing phone.
This doesn't scratch the employer itch, but I think you could use an android VNC viewer app and then run a VNC server targeting a small vertical monitor attached to your workstation.
I imagine pulling up the document that I want to read, putting it on the correct monitor, and then grabbing the tablet and taking it to my hammock for some heads down reading time.
Another plus one from me. I don’t have the same workplace policies, but even for personal use I’d prefer a ‘plain’ monitor.
This is actually what I was hoping to make this summer...
+1
As one of the beta testers, let me just say that I really like this device. It's very different than a kindle, kobo or reMarkable in that the refresh rate really makes a big difference. When I show this device to people, I show them how quickly zooming in on a PDF is. It's way faster and more responsive than any e-ink screen and it's way less addicting than the typical laptop, phone or tablet.
I'm attempting to make this device my main driver over the next few months and while the ecosystem isn't exactly mature yet, most android apps just work out of the box and I've found myself doing a lot more reading, either through an e-reading app (Lithium), PDF reader or Instapaper. I have X, Primal, Telegram and many other apps installed, but I don't go to them nearly as much. The device really is a lot more human centered and it makes for a much more intentional device.
Why did you say "less addicting"?
One common psychological trick addictive social media uses is high saturation color, as it causes our monkey brains to enjoy it slightly more. This is monotone and I’d assume that’s a relevant feature point
On Pixel phone, there is a Digital Wellbeing setting that can turn your screen into Greyscale mode during bedtime. It is said to discourage the use of social networks and helps you sleep better.
I'd recommend giving grayscale mode a try not only during bedtime, but all the time! My Pixel has been set this way for a couple months and it has decreased my mindless phone usage by simply making the phone more boring overall, without any new device or major sacrifices.
I became concerned that I'd turn it off when I temporarily needed color and forget to turn it back on, so instead I used Tasker to listen for L-R shake action and make that temporarily disable grayscale mode for 20 secs (in case I specifically decide I want to look at color in a photo or disambiguate something from grayscale). Works decently well, I can explain the Tasker steps if anyone else is interested.
On my Pixel using GrapheneOS, I can go into Accessibility settings and enable gesture support for toggling Grayscale support, without the need for Tasker. I'm unsure how other Android ROMs stack up but I imagine stock Pixel has this setting.
It's a great feature, just swipe up from the bottom with two fingers whenever I need color.
I'm _almost_ certain that comes with any Android ROM from 9.0 up as a standard accessibility setting. All my Samsung devices have had it for a few years.
Huh, didn't realize that was there! Works on stock Pixel, you're right, definitely useful feature to have
This would eliminate the failure mode of my grayscale attempts. I would appreciate knowing the configuration steps.
No root needed, but you first need to grant Tasker the WRITE_SECURE_SETTINGS permission, see: https://tasker.joaoapps.com/userguide/en/help/ah_secure_sett...
I granted it via ADB using the command line listed, but the other method with app might work too. If you don't have ADB, It's very easy to install by just downloading the right sdk for your OS, and you run the included ADB binary via command line while your phone is plugged in via USB, and USB debugging is enabled (which is an android developer setting).
Set your Android accessibility color correction type to grayscale if you don't have that already. The below Tasker action simply toggles it off and on.
Tasker config is-
Configure a Shake Left-Right event trigger (I recommend sensitivity 'Very Low' and Duration 'Long' to avoid accidental triggers)
Configure a 3-step action following the trigger:
1. Custom Setting
2. Wait action (I set to 20 sec)3. Custom Setting
Set the Collision Handling on the task gear/settings to "Abort Existing Task", so that you can extend the color lifetime by shaking the phone again.Of course, once you have this action in Tasker, you can use any trigger to turn it on or off, like opening a particular app, turning it on when you are only at home or away, etc.
Works pretty well for me, there is one slight issue where some type of android display layout refresh occurs when the color toggle happens, which sometimes refreshes the interface you are on in a slightly annoying way. I tolerate it, it's ok, maybe setting a longer wait period would make this occur less often.
If these steps don't work / too confusing, try using the really great accessibility gesture support setting mentioned in a reply, instead or in addition: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40462366
FYI John Dalton was a scientist who pioneered color blindness research among many other fields, so his name is everywhere in color correction settings apparently.
Amazing, thank you!
I'd love to do the same thing, so if you have time to explain the Tasker steps I'd definitely make use of them :-)
I put the steps in a sibling comment:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40465686
Cheers
Wonderful
I am using gray scale on personal phone permanently, but avoided that on work phone as I might need to discern color in some work documents or screenshares.
What you describe seems like a perfect solution but does it work on all Android phones?
If you could throw some more light on the steps ... appreciate that!
I do think it will work on non-Pixel phones, but you do need to enable Secure Settings for Tasker, which probably can be locked down by Mobile Device Management or other admin control methods that a work device could have.
Listed my config in a sibling comment:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40465686
I've been doing the same for a few months, as I wanted to get an eink phone but wasn't sure how annoying it'd be. Although there's some limitations, like charts or video calls, I got used to it quite quickly in the end. Really recommended, you can just enable it in display settings (at least on my Samsung).
Thanks for the recommendation! I don't have a big mindless phone usage problem but I'll give it a shot anyway and see what happens.
That's Android thing not just Pixel thing
Most devices let you enable a monochrome filter and optionally invert the image somewhere in the accessibility settings, for what it's worth. You don't need a special device just for that.
But nobody does that, because we love addictions.
This.
The screen should slowly desaturate color and eventually switch to b/w when the phone detects mindless scrolling automatically. ;)
Lool like each post you scroll desaturates the screen by 2%
I do it!
I often use ctrl-win-c shortcut for black and white mode in Windows, it's great to rest the eyes.
That's awesome, I had no idea that was a feature, using it now!
On Ubuntu it is not quite like that.
https://github.com/ionutbortis/gnome-bedtime-mode
Yeah, you have to do some installing to get the feature you never knew you needed.
That, and at night a LED device is literally putting a flashlight in direct line of sight, which does not help in making one sleepy (even with night mode stuff cutting some blue light it's still a flashlight, albeit tinted) so more potential for extended late hours doomscrolling. OLED is kind of better than LCD but still.
Comparatively eink relies on ambient lighting (backlighted ones have it backwards in that regard)
For starters, it doesn't come with the whole "light show", it's black and white.
"Minimalist" types often suggest turning your smartphone into B&W mode (usually an accessibility setting), precisely to reduce temptation to watch videos, social media, and such.
Elsewhere in this thread I see comments that mention "low distraction", "calmer", and something about iPhones frying kids' brains.
This all looks like snobbery to me, based on the association of monochrome paper with novels and writing and intellectual pursuits. In the 18th century we were scared that novels would fry the brains of young women, but times have changed and now it's iPhones that are sinful, and monochrome displays are virtuous, apparently.
I think I might be going off the idea of e-ink, as a result. But my particular interest is nostalgia for the illustrators of the 80s. I would like to see a full-color portrait format 16-inch e-ink display or tablet. Preferably as addicting as possible, because outside of actual pharmacology that word just means "fun".
By way of an experiment - set your phone screen to black & white (in iOS, settings -> accessibility -> display -> color filters -> [on] -> grayscale, on android, settings -> accessibility -> color & motion -> color correction -> [on] -> grayscale), and leave it that way for a day of normal use. Then, turn it off, and note how you react to the change.
Folks aren't calling it calmer because they're trying to look erudite, they're calling it calmer because modern applications put a lot of work into capturing your attention, and color is one of the tools they use (quite aggressively) to do so. Disabling color on the device isn't some way to look snobbish, it's a way to reduce the number of ways the device and applications are attempting to grab your attention.
I created a shortcut to toggle grayscale for iOS. Try it out!
https://www.icloud.com/shortcuts/371d5ced520d40e984d626ae304...
Since IIRC Shortcuts is actually pretty clunky, it's probably easier to use Control Center to toggle grayscale, which is possible after you add the control named "accessibility shortcuts" using {settings > control center}. That is what I use.
(And on Gnome, I use and recommend the following: https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/4012/gnome-bedtime/)
On iOS, you can also set up the “accessibility shortcut” (settings -> accessibility -> accessibility shortcut), which lets you triple-click the home button to enable it.
You can also have the back tap (double or triple) run the accessibility shortcut.
I use triple-back for "grayscale" (because I found myself double-tapping the back accidentally all the time.)
Thank you so much for this! Not having to dig through the settings to toggle B&W makes it much more workable.
You can also create automations to turn grayscale back off for apps that need it. I have ones for maps, photos and whatsapp (since people send a lot of pics in my group). They run when the app is activated/deactivated.
Just ignore them? Don't use manipulative apps?
I suppose for some people this is an issue and they genuinely want a physical solution in order to stop habitually doing things they don't like, like Odysseus wanting to be tied to the mast to avoid the Sirens.
I can predict how my behavior would change if I tried this: I'd be pissed off because you'd ruined my game of Heroes III (1999). And Brogue would be slightly less pretty. Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead would be much the same, and news sites and coding wouldn't change much. So my reaction would just be "this is gloomy", it's not like I need freeing from a hypnotic spell.
Hmmm..the way you're arguing against makes it seem like you're being manipulated. Maybe you have an issue too?
If you don't want to use it then don't. I'm not even sure why you're in here arguing against it.
https://www.wired.com/story/our-minds-have-been-hijacked-by-...
To recap, somebody mentioned addiction, to colors presumably, as a reason to prefer a monochrome display, and I thought that was ridiculous. So I said so. People didn't react well.
I've read a little part of the article. I don't much like the giant tech and social media companies. However, when I come to phrases like this:
I can't bear to continue wading through it. This is just moral panic. A marginal effect of keeping an audience's attention - sometimes - for a little while - is exaggerated by people who (again, like me) dislike the big tech companies, and described like an actual addictive drug. This seems dishonest. But perhaps they actually believe it. No doubt there have been studies that tell them what they want to hear.
But yeah, moral panic, or maybe virtue signalling, or tribalism - something like that is going on here, and realism suffers, and I don't like that, so I said something. I don't know if anybody appreciated me saying something, because maybe it was off-message, but I'm saying it anyway. I'm not claiming to be super-smart, I'm generally a foolish person, and I'm getting a lot of veiled insults here, I suppose because I pissed on your oddly monochrome strawberries.
Again, I'd encourage you to actually give it a try. It's quick, and I think it would give you some insights into the things people are actually saying and why they're saying them.
Well, that's exactly what many social media addicts do need.
I had no idea this was possible, wow, very cool! I turned this on and I’m going to try it out. I kind of love the idea of a grayscale screen and I had no clue I owned one already!
I agree with you that people tend to grossly overestimate the bad effects of a new technology. For example my kids cringe if they catch me or my wife looking at YouTube shorts. My son - that has complete, unlimited access to his gaming PC, installed a Firefox extension to block YouTube shorts. I think the problem will self-regulate at some point.
However I made my iPhone black and white as suggested by others and I love it, I believe I'll keep it like this for a few days because it looks so cool. We will see if it leads to less usage.
The main benefit of e-ink isn't what you mentioned in the post, imo, it is that it is great to read with in everything from direct sunlight to darkness, which is less straining for the eyes.
Having something mainly for reading is also a nice thing for us that easily get distracted away from that.
You say it like it is a bad thing. It is associated with novels and writing and intellectual pursuits, because it's less suitable for video/graphics focused social media, videos, and games.
False analogy aside, we already know TVs and then smartphones are addictive in a way older media never were. We already have studies about that, and we already have statistics about the dire consequences on teenagers and adults in many metrics.
So, your argument is a little like saying:
"In the 1940s and 50s we were scared that weed would fry the brains of young kids, but times have changed and now it's meth that is dangerous, and weed is ok, apparently".
Well, meth is hella dangerous, and that's a fact, even if they overblew the danger of weed in the 1940s.
It's an American term that means 'less addictive.'
For one, images and videos are a lot less visually stimulating. Everything is in black and white, and though those all render fine, they're just not as interesting as they would be in full color. So instead of doomscrolling Youtube shorts, I find myself doing more reading, particularly of books since the epub reading experience is fantastic and causes much less eye strain.
I was playing at an outdoor concert recently - last year I suffered from the combination of paper sheet music + wind.. so this year I used an Android tablet in portrait mode where I could flicker to the next one relatively easily with a finger (no fancy bluetooth pedal control or anything). Me, wind: 1-0. This particular tablet was actually visible in full daylight when I turned the screen light to its maximum.
After this I've been thinking how nice a Kindle-style display would be (not to mention battery), the more sunlight the better, kind of. A Kindle is too small, and well.. I know there are others (that Remarkable someone mentioned), but..
What about this Daylight one? Overkill maybe?
Onyx Boox Air 3 10.3’ is great for sheet music! I'm using it and enjoy getting away from ton of papers.
Get non C version with better contrast ratio and longer battery life.
Kobo makes an eight inch e-reader for $270. That's about two inches larger than even a fairly large e-ink reader. It has hardware page turn buttons, I think, but the screen can also be tapped.
Or the Boox Note 3c, which has a 10" screen (don't go for the color screen, the contrast ratio is much worse), also has a front light, $400: https://shop.boox.com/products/noteair3 with the added advantage of running Android 12, so you can install a sheetmusic specific app.
Or there's this $400 transflexive display android tablet, B&W only (not even grayscale) and no backlight:
https://goodereader.com/blog/reviews/unboxing-the-hisense-q5...
What is your experience with writing code on the device? Does the grayscale impact syntax highlighting?
Yea, grayscale definitely impacts the syntax highlighting, as many of the colors end up pretty dark.
It works, though, and I have coded a bit on it. My only criticism would be that the copy-pasting is a little clunky, at least with JuiceSSH. Maybe other apps would be better at it.
What's the experience like with using it as a Terminal coding app? I'm super interested in using this to SSH into a home machine and programming from this.
How viable is that?
Though even if the device works excellently for that, i'm not sure it would _feel_ good due to it not being a laptop. My wife's ipad pro for example is not nearly as comfy as my mac pro, due to the properly balanced weight of it all.
Still, super tempting to try this.. i've wanted this for so long.
I've got JuiceSSH set up and use the device as a thin client. Coding is a little different since you don't get the terminal colors that you normally use for syntax highlighting. Still, it's functional, and I can do it, mostly using a bluetooth keyboard to do so.
It says you can install any Android app. So I can just like browse websites in Firefox? How is that experience?
I'm typing on a Daylight computer on Firefox right now with the brightness turned to 0 so it's only reflecting light. It's very similar to the tablet experience for Hacker News, just with less color, so it's not as straining to the eye.
Xorg is still able to do 1bpp. Windows has a grayscale filter. Don't know if you can still get to render dithered B&W.
a lot of applications (especially GTK3/4) will go buggy if they open at all on 1bpp display. Generally anything that does not report TrueColor RGBA8888 or RGBx8888 as first visual will trip them up.
Is there a good app for note taking like on remarkable?
There's a stylus that comes with it and lots of note-taking apps. I particularly like the ability to take notes directly in PDFs, which for technical papers can be very helpful.
I have a hard time getting a sense of what the display is really like from the website and the embedded video (it cuts too quickly, uses depth of field shots of the tablet, etc).
Given that this is all about a new display, it would be nice to show a more pragmatic demo video right upfront. A demo that gives a clear look at how the display behaves with respect to lighting, reflections, animation, touch screen, etc. That's what I would look for when deciding to buy this.
Maybe YouTube reviewers will end up providing this information...
The lack of any 3rd party hands-on video reviews was the biggest red flag that halted any consideration I had to purchase this product.
they're coming!! but i appreciate your skepticism until there's more video proof, i am the same
too many broken promises by other tech cos, i understand we have to earn your trust
there should be more video reviews coming out on twitter though from early customers / testers
.. if i wasnt drowning in launch, id try to find you a link, if anyone else could help !
Publishing a sped-up video without telling us that it's sped up really killed all my trust I had in you guys. Seriously, what were you thinking? Your main and only selling point is the speed. So much so that that needs to compensate for lack of other features like resolution and color. And then you open the door to cheating accusations? You can now 100x say that it's really fast and no ghosting and all that, but your ethics seem to really believe it was no big deal, so at each turn down the line I'll have to question, perhaps here they also didn't think it's a big deal to pull some dirty trick?
So disappointed. :(
Killed my trust also, "drowning in launch" is no excuse for not rectifying this immediately.
Posting a real-time video right now would take five minutes and clear up all this bad publicity right when they need to.
There are other real time videos on this page https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-493382
I've seen that page - it has 16 videos and it's unclear which are sped up, by how much, and which aren't. Some look sped up to my eye, and even if they aren't, I simply can't trust they aren't because they've shown they won't inform me so.
This is a super bad look for a new product offering whose entire killer feature and market differentiation is based on its supposed blazing speed.
Posting ANY video that's sped up, without clearly labelling by exactly how much, and when (eg, with a "3x speed" text overlay as is almost standard on internet video), is a huge mistake introducing a product differentiating on speed.
It's documentation. Sure, they could add the speed of the videos, but honestly, I want it optimized for showing me how to use the feature, not serving something it's not: marketing material.
Apple does this as well in it's documentation, and no one complains. Lots of companies do this. So, complaining about the documentation being optimized as documentation is silly in my eyes.
The page where the videos are from isn't meant to be marketing material. It's a documentation page for people who already have the tablet -- the page says "Welcome to Your Daylight Computer". I personally have no qualms if some of the videos there are sped up, and it has no bearing on my trust of the company.
If you want the promotional videos actually advertising/backing the display claims, check out the main website: https://daylightcomputer.com/product . If you do find evidence that the video there is sped up, I agree with you it's a bad look. But the videos look pretty clearly not sped up based on the human motion.
Regardless there will be third party videos popping on YouTube soon, as the parent comment says.
Many of us seem to have ended up at that documentation page out of exasperation, as we couldn't find video examples on the main page.
It appears that portrait vs landscape on their main page, on mobile at least, conceals that promo video (which does appear to show realtime footage).
If you happen to visit in the wrong orientation (or whatever other variables hide the video) and see claims of speed, but conspicuously absent proof, and then discover quietly sped-up videos buried in the docs, it all starts to feel scammy.
Given e-ink has a history of all kinds of shenanigans, and given I believe this company launched then unlaunched this product a few weeks ago (setting videos to private), it's not surprising some of us are on a hair-trigger.
Anyway, having seen decent enough video now, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt. If this is for real, it will be of huge benefit to many who struggle with artificial light sensitivity, and I'm sure they'll do well.
For future reference, if you're going to make a claim like this, seriously include a link. It's unclear what video you're talking about.
Assuming you're talking about the link to a video posted by another commenter further down ( https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=mikhailt ), that video was posted out of context. There are a lot of other videos on that documentation page which are not sped up. See here: https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-493382
The video in question, the video under "ereader on steroids", appears to be sped up, my guess is because the purpose of the video is to summarize the functionality. A "3x" label would be nice, but let's not jump to accusations! That video isn't at all in a context where it seems likely meant to mislead. You can view other videos on that page that are in 1x.
Oops I meant to link to here. This is the comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40459851
What do you do with all the time you save on capitals and punctuation?
To answer this question as someone who often writes messages the same way… typing that way isn’t actually much faster, but it’s often more enjoyable. It also helps to convey a more informal and relaxed tone.
I have both rM and rM2. I reverse engineered the rM refresh API and made an open-source framework out of it. This device looks very interesting and I actually wanted to grab one to play with but the next batch ships so far into the future that I decided to wait.
If you could send me a unit (which I'll of course pay for) on a more accelerated schedule, I'd love to explore the device. Let me know.
Looking forward to the MKBHD review
You can see the videos here: https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-509983
Thank you! This quick overview is helpful: https://player.vimeo.com/video/922512661
It looks like the speed of the video is at 1.25 or something like that. The hand/finger moves kinda un-naturally. Is it just me?
Either way, it looks great. I do watch some YT vids, but I focus on the audio (i.e. watching some urgent news on Sky News (live) - video detail is not as important when something very bad has happened).
It's about 3x. At 19-20s time goes from 5:44 to 5:45, at 40s it goes from 5:45 to 5:46.
That's pretty misleading and borderline deceptive. They should release a real-time video.
There are other videos here: https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-493382 . That one video appears to have been sped up, my guess is to try to show a "summary" of functionality. I tried a few of the other videos and they don't appear to be sped up.
Yeah, for something where the performance is actually a selling point, you should probably feel obliged to include a clock or some other reference in the image. (I'm not claiming anything about this particular video - just that you really want to eliminate the perception of impropriety here.) This was a big problem in robotics for years - it eventually became standard to still do sped up videos but be disciplined about including labels, and robots finally got to plausible speeds at actual tasks - but it didn't take much early-on fakery to get people to assume that most videos were sped up.
(There's a lot of staging and other "creative presentation" that's legitimate marketing - but if you're talking about speed/responsiveness at all, you really need to be explicit.)
I think context matters; that specific video is meant to show a summary of the functionality; it's in a section called "ereader on steroids" and it doesn't say anything about speed. And there are a lot of other videos on the same page which are not sped up. https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-493382
Labelling the speed would be nice, but I don't detect any bad intentions here.
https://player.vimeo.com/video/921370292
Appears to be the original speed version.
Wrong link?
This should be the right link
https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-493382
(points to the section where you can see videos)
https://player.vimeo.com/video/922512661
If you click on "Get to Know the Daylight Computer" section it has some videos.
I've tried it and it's extraordinary. Is it worth it, at this price, to you? That's something only you can answer. But it's unlike anything you've ever seen. I agree that it needs to be seen to be understood and hopefully they can get in retail outlets at some point.
Please, tell me there's a phone coming along. Light Phone made a mistake not going Android. You totally nailed it with that casually dropped Spotify icon in that shot!
I personally have zero use for a tablet. But if I can have an eink phone, with all the authentication apps I need to connect to work and do banking (and maps and Spotify), I'll drop that iPhone that is frying the brains of my kids instantly.
See the Minimal E-ink phone
They were still making major design changes just one week ago (first completely removing, then providing a front-facing camera option after previously changing the screen dimensions and device form factor). There's basically no way it ships on their timeline (currently Sept 2024), if it ships at all. They nailed the slick marketing, but have been full of nonsensical timelines and promises.
https://www.thelightphone.com/
An e ink phone already exists, in reality. I don’t know why you would hold out hope for a Kickstarter.
I've been using the light phone 2 off and on for the past year. It's too painful to use.
How so? I’d like to hear why
I own the Light Phone 2 and do like it a lot, but it's a bit too limited and some of the promises of Minimal would solve some of the pain points that Light hasn't managed to, so I definitely see the appeal.
But everything I've seen indicates that Minimal is going to be heavily delayed, if it's not an outright scam. Meanwhile, the Light Phone 2 has been around for years now, and they're planning to release updated hardware later this year.
Off-topic, but anyone know if Google Fi would make it easy to switch between two phones without too much hassle?
I'd love to have a second phone that I could take around when I'm not expecting to do any photography or anything. (I know, I could have a dedicated camera instead, but I take pictures on my phone...)
They provide free data-only sim cards. And you used to be able to sync all of your texts and calls in the hangout app, but they got rid of that. The last time I tried syncing the Messages app to a data o my device, it didn't work too well. That was a while ago though so not sure if that is still the case.
Swapping sim cards is probably too much of a hassle. You could just make the epaper phone your primary, and drag along the second phone as needed. Also, there is no reason an epaper phone can't take photos. Plenty of camera gear out there where the viewfinder/preview screen is a very poor preview of the final image and regardless, most folks just snap away with their phones and look at the images later. Modern smartphones do most of the work regarding camera settings.
I would love that, but really doubt any company is going to put out a phone with a great camera and an epaper screen.
The Boox Palma doesn't have a cell connection but is a phone-sized Android based e-paper tablet.
I've never owned an android, but for any android folks: how do you all think about device security/privacy when the manufacture is relatively unknown and overseas?
I really wanted to get one, but didn't know the risks associated with this.
Completely untrustworthy.
I have a Likebook e-ink android device and it's great, except for the fact that I can't trust the software at all.
I just assume it has a root kit on it.
The faster refresh isn't even what excites me about the daylight, it's the fact that it's a more trustworthy vendor (hopefully).
I tried grapheneos, and it’s great out of the box. It’s snappy, 3x manufacturer claimed battery life, and the camera sort of works (everything else did except the pixel fast charger).
However, to run third party apps (especially those that use GPS, including lyft and uber), you have to install the Google Play Services, which are sandboxed, but cut the battery life by 66% back to the manufacturer claims (so I assume at least some of the continuous surveillance crap was running / successfully phoning home).
On top of that, at any given time, 5-10% of apps would crash on startup.
They gave java stacktraces saying they got an unchecked null pointer exception when looking for random system services. The set of apps would change randomly over time, as companies only test on android, and take a while to fix such low-priority bugs.
Also, it was missing a bunch of functionality I take for granted on iPhone, and that I ended up needing (like crdt-based notes).
On the bright side, android’s non-carplay bluetooth support is miles ahead of iOS.
Tl:dr: Degoogled android would be nice, but don’t bother.
Yea I was recently considering a Boox device but this turned me against it. It’s not even running a recent version of Android (only Android 11).
Find out their update policy. I wouldn't buy a device not matching or exceeding 7 years of OS upgrades / Security patches.
I don’t think this is necessarily true. I use reMarkable almost purely because it’s not an android tablet.
I have a remarkable and a boox; I only use the boox in the end because it’s Android and I can actually do things on it…
The HiSense A5, A7 and A9 range of phones could be your answer. Problem is it is a Chinese domestic market phone. A9 does have a GSI of LineageOS with working EINK refresh modes available on XDA so this could be your ticket if the 4G bands are available in your country (basically not the US).
I have an A5 Pro and it works great.
light phone is android though...
https://www.reddit.com/r/LightPhone/comments/jqtfu4/heres_ho...
root too... https://www.reddit.com/r/LightPhone/comments/jqtfu4/comment/...
I've been using an e-ink phone (HiSense A9) full-time for a year, and it's pretty great. Especially things like biking navigation in sunlight are a huge plus.
The Daylight Computer technology is super interesting and a friend of mine that saw one at some tech festival a while ago said it really is that good. Unfortunately an Android tablet is about the least interesting product you could make with that technology, for me. A phone, a laptop or a full-size computer monitor would be a different game.
They commented on Twitter saying they’ll use profits from the tablet towards making a phone
Can I run my own software on it? I would love to buy an epaper portable of some sort, but the fact that they're all locked down is a no go. One day I'll live my dream of vim in the forest grove.
yup yes, we will release a bootloader unlock tool so you can do whatever you want
This completely changes the chances that I'll buy this. I love the idea, but I just can't see myself ever buying an android device that is running Google's panopticon. I also noticed there's nothing on the product page about privacy, and was about to write this off as another nice gadget that I'd never be able to use.
I'm very hopeful with an unlocked bootloader that the community will provide a more privacy-focused operating system so that I can enjoy this product.
Same for me, if your product asks me to login with google I'm out. Just out.
I've considered, for instance, getting a fair phone. But the only way to get a pre-de-googled one is through a third party at a 20% premium..
I'm currently using an old iPhone, but my plan once it finally dies is to buy a pixel phone and immediately wipe it and install Graphene. It seems really weird to buy a google device if I want better privacy, but based on the research I've done it really does seem like the best option if you value privacy, are willing to deal with a little bit of pain to get privacy, but also need a phone that can at least sometimes do things like run banking apps that force you into the panopticon of bullshit.
I know you specifically said pre-de-googled, but as you said it seems like the options there are really bad, but graphene does seem to make it pretty easy to install (although I haven't actually tried it yet).
If an unlocked bootloader would satisfy you for this device, then surely the Fairphone should be good for you too? At least for the FP4, you don't even need the CLI or anything - just install the desktop app [1], connect your phone, and run the app.
[1] https://doc.e.foundation/easy-installer
I would sign up for a mailing list for when this is available, I will probably actually buy one if it's android with root.
This will be a "killer feature" for the crowd here for many reasons.
This product would also make for a classy home automation tablet.
Just pitching in to say this is also very important to me.
Upon hearing this (and seeing the software that you've got listed on the website) I went and bought one. Looks great!
If you really do this it would be a fantastic incentive for me. Just knowing the community can tinker makes a product feel more my own rather than "rented" like some systems out there.
THANK YOU!
There is so much hardware out there people could be hacking on, improving, repressing all wasted due to difficulty loading new code.
A coworker was given a SONY e-ink device. We quite like it, but the included firmware is limited and dependent on a windows app that leaves a lot to be desired.
This is early hardware that was given the SONY treatment. That means great enclosure and ergonomics, but also conservative use of the display and goofy proprietary interfaces.
Would not take much to make the device a lot more useful.
One day, we will circle around and be talking about these already solid devices and how in-demand they remain despite their age because of your great decision.
Sidebar: I really want one, but am price constrained at the moment. (Too bad, so sad for me!)
Will the production models see an equally open configuration?
Hope so. Thanks again.
This got you another order
okay, now I'm very interested.
Another massive plus.
World needs more boot loader unlocked devices.
I imagine you’ll get Linux distributions within a week or so.
Let me know when it's out!
—Owner of a bricked e-ink device
That would be any Android tabled - supposedly E-Ink based - with Termux installed...
Yes, although to satisfy my dream of vim in the forest grove, that vim needs to be capable of opening and writing every (text) file on the filesystem, meaning it needs root
100% this, it's a computer let me compute.
I've used vim from the reMarkable and a C interpreter in a root shell when my laptop was broken. On-screen keyboard wasn't the best experience though
I haven't done a ton of usage outdoors, but my boox max lumi works for this. IIUC the android it runs is "unlocked" so I think you could use it as a computer if you wanted. I use it as a tablet and a monitor.
Would you license this to others at a more affordable rate than e-ink? Lenovo has some e-ink 2-in-1 "thinkbook" laptops and might be a good partner... I'm sure you're considered this already.
Personally I am sold on the 'low distraction and eye strain' of e-ink, and would be keen on buying a computer with that display. That said, I'm more interested in a general computer running a general operating system (ubuntu or any linux) if I'm using something for daily work. Even if your own operating system can do these things I would be concerned with edge-cases for software I need for work, so for professional daily usage I need an OS that is battle-tested, and not based on a locked-down sandboxed mobile system like android where I'd have to fight the OS to do what I want.
I do own and use a remarkable, so I'm probably in the target market. I only use the remarkable for note taking, it's handy for freehand sketching visual ideas or concepts digitally, where typing or any sort of computer drawing with a mouse may add friction that gets in the way of getting the ideas down onto paper. The main advantage over paper is so I don't need to worry about misplacing the pieces of draft paper afterwards, when I revisit an idea months later.
I definitely don't want a tablet for typing code. If I'm going to carry around an external keyboard, I might as well just get a thin-and-light laptop.
I almost bought the aforementioned thinkbook with the e-ink display. Main reason I didn't was that I was worried about compatibility issues if I ran linux, since it's designed for windows.
I bet people would pay good money for a Framework display module that's usable eInk. (Assuming it can use the same display connector.)
https://frame.work/products/display-kit?v=FRANGX0001
https://guides.frame.work/Guide/Display+Replacement+Guide/86...
https://x.com/zephray_wenting/status/1535041457035280392
Very, very, very interesting. It must be this one:
https://github.com/Modos-Labs/Glider
Cool. Is it strictly black and white? I see no grayscale.
Wenting Zhang made a proof of concept for this, it's somewhere on his Twitter, Youtuhe, or Github :)
Definetly would be amazing to have for the Framework.
Seems like they'll be shipping dev kits on crowd supply soon. Was posted on HN last week:
Glider – open-source eInk monitor with an emphasis on low latency https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40358309
Oh my god I would buy this in a heartbeat (specifically the RLCD display - I've used enough kindle-style e-ink displays to find them basically unusable for anything I'm intending to actually interact with).
I'd sell my kidney for that.
I'd buy a framework laptop just for that.
I would buy one.
They are just using displays made by eInk. Technically, Linfiny Japan Inc., which is a subsidiary that does B2B stuff like large displays.
Several companies are offering similar fast refresh tech. It's no longer anything super special.
"We developed our own custom epaper display tech we call LivePaper. ... Note: it’s 60fps epaper, not off the shelf Eink"
Why do you claim it's off the shelf eInk when they explicitly say it isn't?
Yes 2-in-1 is very interesting and useful device, the latest one version has color e-ink [1].
For non-color e-ink sporting 60fps display in low-cost laptop with Intel entry level N100 CPU would be awesome as working and learning gadgets, and batteries should last days instead of hours.
[1] Meet the Lenovo ThinkBook Plus Twist
https://youtu.be/ZBV_VGsVqqE
This. Lenovo never quite managed to get their act together with the e-paper side of their 2-in-1.
- Maybe this is what's missing?
- ...maybe you could do you own 2-in-1?
Any chance of the A4 size device and higher DPI in the future? Will pay any money for that.
A4 e-ink has considerable audience that doesn't know they need it – people who read papers. All the academia is formatted for A4 and stored in PDFs, which is pretty unreadable even on 10". People literally print them on paper to read.
I currently enjoying A4-sized Boox Tab X and it's a game changer, as I read a lot of papers and want to read more outside. Love it so much, and having Android is important (instead of some own walled OS), as I can sync my papers via ReadCube Papers app. I also tried to use it as a monitor for coding, but even with their superrefresh technology refresh rate is still a problem.
yes, academia should totally love this, but my experience is that they just all got used to reading papers on their laptops or tablets.
but I would totally love this. in fact, I have a remarkable tablet just for reading "papers" (ahem Dungeons & Dragons PDFs). but switching quickly between pages is tricky there...
That depends. Back in the day, in my research institute, it was common practice to print out the papers that should be read thoroughly - after skimming them on a Laptop screen.
I read most papers on a secondary 19" monitor that's mounted portrait. Seems to cover all the requirements
Not all ones not mentioned in this thread yet. A secondary 19" monitor ties you to a desk. A tablet would allow reading wherever people typically read paper printouts (in the train, while sitting on a couch, etc.)
You're not wrong. But in those scenarios, I tend to be off the clock
When I have a complex paper to read I will spread it out on the floor. A single page at a time is too limiting, I want to be able to see page 5 and page 12 at the same time.
It was nice to be able to jot things down in the margins (math, not just notes). Provide yourself the couple steps the author skipped (to show how clever they are).
There's only a certain number of papers you can carry around and flip through like that. With a tablet, it can store hundreds or thousands of papers without getting any more unwieldy.
I've been waiting for 10 years for a A4 e-ink device. Only Sony made one, but it was never available anywhere. And pretty meh probably too :)
Remarkable 2 was pretty decent for notes, but terrible for reading imo. And the bs to get a proper ebook app on it etc was just too much for me.
Try Onyx Boox Tab X. I found it to be the only viable option now and it's really good. They did some own stuff to have "ultrafast" refresh rate (you can choose desirable tradoff some ghosting for refresh rate). Stylus and notes are pretty good too.
I’m guessing letter would be fine too, given how many times I’ve printed out European papers here in the states.
A stylus would help a lot a that point too. So would a hole in the tablet where you can store the stylus — my apple sits and collects dust with a dead battery. I bought it for occasional use, and it’s never ready when I need it, even at home.
I do use a newer boox android eink tablet for coding via termux and ssh. Great for my needs. I wonder how this compares.
They know it very well. There's been a void for an affordable eInk device for this purpose for decades.
So this is an advanced form of reflective LCD? Interesting. LTT recently tested a color display like that too[0].
A few Questions: Why is it black and white? Does the Image stay the same when the device is off? What is the surface like for the Pen? Is the Display recessed so there's parallax between pen and Display or is it laminated like an iPad? How is the repairability? Can the battery be replaced easily? How is software support going to be? Since I'm supposed to link all kinds of cloud accounts to it, I would not buy this without a statement regarding security updates and support lifetime.
Looks cool though! [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c0TcGjzKbag
1) black & white because bayer color filter will cut your brightness by 66%
2) alas we gave up bistability for speed, so the image doesn't stay when you turn it off (however, we maybe can do quasi-bistability with this tech for watch or kindle sized future devices)
3) the pen writing feel is similar to my favorite japanese paper campus kokoyu. you could argue comparable to a remarkable or maybe even better for some
4)its all laminated / optically bonded
5) we can improve on repairability, its fine, but nothing stand out. we have big plans in the future here though
6) we're aiming to build the business on customer trust so we better be good at software updates! android is hard though, so its definitely a learning curve and requires a lot of resources
7) we'll do better to earn your trust around using our accounts - lots of plans in the coming months and years to be the best privacy + security + sovereignty computers!
Some more questions about software support. It seems the device is using android. Do you have any plan to support mainline linux kernel? It could allow the possibility to use native linux distro like PostmarketOS (https://postmarketos.org/) for device longevity. Your team could also benefit from delegating some softare support effort to linux kernel team.
we're open to it! we just need to better understand what resources we need internally to support this effort and for the specific mediatek/qualcomm chips we're looking at
What specific mediatek/qaulcom chips are you looking at? It says you've already shipped two batches, so I assume that's been decided?
If a standard linux image is produced, I would potentially replace my laptop with this device.
Given the level of excitement around this, and the community expertise, if I were you I'd open up as much of the info as you legally can and let the community help. I think there's a decent chance that if you set up the framework, you may not have to do much to get it done. I would:
1. Create a github page where you include as much of the hardware info as you can
2. Include any custom kernel patches that you have for the hardware (I'm pretty sure this is legally required anyway because of GPL on the kernel, so this could double as fulfillment of publishing/distribution)
3. Let people go at it! Early on I expect a community leader (usually a top contributor) will emerge that you can work with to get it done. I suspect you wouldn't have to do a whole lot (beyond information sharing) to get stuff mainlined and even prebuilt distros assembled for the device!
Even if it doesn't work, it's not a big investment and it gives you a massive amount of credibility with the community.
Huh????? I feel cheated after reading this. Only using power for screen changes is half the point of e-ink!
It sounds like they're calling it e-paper because it's a variable refresh reflective LCD, not e-ink.
Yeah it's the exact same thing that pebble did. They used Sharp low energy self-refreshing LCD
7) hits home for me. This is already buy worthy.
Same. This coming shift in computing looks to be ugly and closed to a higher degree. Makes me want to support anything like this.
I think the average person (myself included) does not know that something can be considered ePaper without being bistable. The two are married in my head because all of the ePaper devices that I've been exposed to thus far have been bistable. If I were you, I would find a clever way to communicate this fact without making it sound like too much of a drawback.
Sell me a massive desktop e-ink display with USB-C input. I want to code on this.
https://shop.dasung.com ?
Ok you are my favorite person now. Thanks
https://www.reddit.com/r/eink/comments/qjw0xo/just_got_a_das...
not mentioned: 3 year lifespan
I think Monoprice had one at one point. And I think boox makes a monitor. I looked into it last year but never pulled the trigger.
Consider if you really want B/W for coding.
(E-Ink colour displays, Kaleido3 for speed, do not come in "large" size - if you do not consider the exceptional ~60'' made for showrooms.)
yeah, I tried that once and instantly realized the magnitude of information that is conveyed via color alone by syntax highlighting. Color is mandatory for me
Same, but a laptop. I can even code over SSH, but the weight ratio for laptop usage needs to be right.
It's not really e-ink, it's more like transflective LCD, you can buy entire screens from guys like SunVision, LTT did a thing: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c0TcGjzKbag
You might also like these: https://shop.boox.com/products/mira
I'm using https://store.bigme.vip/products/worlds-1st-all-in-one-pc-wi... ... or rather: I have it next to my Dell. I think some of the issues "why" may be addressed by a software update later, some by moving to a sunnier country.
Big reMarkable 2 fan here, and it's very intriguing to see some competition to traditional eInk!
Coming from the rM2, my immediate concerns are display density, and impact of the light on writing feel (both reMarkable and Ratta claim that feel suffers with the extra space between the pen tip and display).
Also as someone who makes a lot of pdf-based tools for the reMarkable, I'd love to see a video or details about the built-in pdf (and epub, hopefully!) reader
Source: I was the chief hardware engineer for this device.
The problem with eink tablets is that they must use front light, and not backlight due to how eink works. This means there is an extra layer in front of the layer where the pixels are, which causes parallax effects which makes writing feel fake. This is (likely) why remarkable deleted the frontlight from their product.
Whereas with the daylight tablet, we have a trans reflective display and a backlight. Since the backlight layer is behind the layer where the pixels are, the parallax does not suffer.
I find the experience of writing with a Wacom EMR pen on mine very pleasing :)
I did not pick up on the frontlight/backlight distinction when reading the overview, thanks! Seems like some very novel tech here, I'd love to see more technical details when they're revealed
I was really impressed by the Kindle Scribe pen input. I don't suppose you've compared that and the Daylight side by side?
Actually that might make an interesting video, going through basic workflows on different tablets.
You are burying the lead here.
This is a big deal, competitors like Onyx Boox don't do this.
And yes, it's annoying.
Reading through the specs I was pleasantly surprised to see Wacom EMR on the list, I enjoy it on my laptop and seems like it would be a great choice here. Best of luck to you and the team!
1) remarkable & ratta are traditional off the shelf eink and have to use a frontlight (above the display) which has many tradeoffs
2) daylight actually uses microperforations in our LivePaper display, so we're able to use a backlight, which in our opinion is superior in multiple ways
one of which, is what you're describing! our backlight doesnt affect writing feel or distance from pen tip to display!
(also way better contrast with BLU on with backlight)
3) thats awesome! feel free to reach out if you want to collaborate, we want to build the best PDF experiences out there as we're serious about knowledge work
anjan at daylightcomputer.com
we will share more details about our pdf reader later this summer when we do an official software launch!
Very cool! Thank you, I will be following closely and may convince myself to join Batch 3 :) And will probably reach out in a few days (I'm sure you're quite busy right now!)
Ratta (SuperNote) does not have front light. At least the A6X that I have. I don't think that the new version (Nomad) has a front light either.
Is it 100% open source? Or is it a device that I'm going to be locked in like mobile phones? Are any chances that the price goes down? I think now this is a factor that prevents me from buying it.
What would lock you in? It's Android, most of your data on apps is going to be saved to the cloud on individual accounts, and pdfs are going to be yours. I'm not sure what would lock you in.
That's absolutely something I do not want after paying almost 800 dollars. Why do you assume that I want to sync my data to the cloud? I maybe want to rsync my stuff to another device of my own. Will I need an account to access the Android store? Again something I don't either want and dislike. And finally will I need to customize it to have root access? I also don't want to do that, I should fully own the thing and do whatever I want. That's what I meant.
Can't you just get Syncthing or Termux (for rsync) from fdroid? That's what I do on any Android. No cloud bullshit or account in Google necessary.
Sure, I can. And I do on my mobile phone cause is the most covenient and fast thing to do and don't have much of a choice.
But why do I need to put termux on a device when it is already running a full-fledged linux? How would you feel if tomorrow you are forced to use Docker just because you can't have root access to your PC? For me it doesn't make any sense at all.
I'm really disappointed of seeing cool stuff locked down by default. Why? Why not be a nice player and go full open source from day one? Is that really hard thing to do? Do they lose anything by doing so?
Or at least when I turn on the device for the first time give me options to choose from:
a) A regular Android. b) An Android that has full root access. c) Run a regular Linux. d) Something else.
In any case the user should easily be able to change to any of the above once running.
Is that asking too much for 800 bucks and for a device that has just entered the market?
I need to preface by saying that I wholeheartedly agree with your overarching point. Everyone should truly own their devices which means at least unlocked bootloader, full root access. I also agree that vendor customised androids are also frequently annoying. That said I don't really agree with this take:
Android is not a full-fledged Linux. It's linux kernel to be sure, but it never pretended to have usual (GNU) userspace. It even uses its own libc. Under this circumstance, I am not sure why it's unusual to have to install an extra package to get a foreign userspace working. It's not particularly different from when you have to use system package manager to install a different shell in your Debian or different libc in Alpine linux e.g. They could go full open source (like AOSP) and this situation wouldn't be any different.
Well, at minimum you are going to need an input method to make syscalls. Most people find it more convenient to run software, such as bash and vim, that talks to glibc that eventually makes syscalls to the kernel on your behalf.
I think what you're asking is why termux isn't bundled with android and the answer to that seems straightforward without even considering ulterior motives: it's more than a hundred megabytes. Maybe 1% of people would use it if you're lucky, and people have a word for large pre-installed software package they didn't want: bloatware
I think we're on the same side but the argument you're using is weird. Linux is a kernel and if you meant distribution then there are still many systems that don't ship a terminal but are still free and open source software
What I think you're trying to argue for is the broader point of it being locked down. Why isn't Termux allowed in Google's store anymore? Why can you not fulfill GPL requirements in their store (you'd need to make a quine)? Why do you need to pass a dozen warning screens and lots of fearmongering online before you get to a state where you've got full access to your own device? Why do many software developers try to detect that state and then refuse to work with you? These are the lock-downs, not that you need to go and "apt install" the software you want to use
The ability to do whatever they want is what they lose when you're in control. DRM being one of the main applications, security is often (mostly incorrectly) touted as a reason for what's actually thwarting competition. And I'll grant them that it actually makes sense for non-techies (my grandma manages to activate the weirdest things that are hidden in menus and behind very clearly worded confirmation dialogs, while claiming she was trying to add a phone book contact), but for someone who enabled developer tools and successfully entered a tar command (xkcd reference) it does not. Businesses might want to lock down their work devices, that's a legit reason for locking down as well, but that's not applicable for phones where MDM is not enabled. The only consumer advantage of a DRM'd phone is that a second hand purchaser can be reasonably certain there's no modifications to the OS without having to know how to re-flash it. I don't think that's a good enough reason to justify it, but I did want to acknowledge there are legitimate/objective advantages to it as well even if I disagree with the overall status quo
I need you to tell me. Why are you not selling these as components for others to integrate? If this is truly better, and you hold patents, you would get zillions orders. Every hobbyist under the sun would buy this.
Because that would make it a shit commodity business and you’d have too little value over the manufacturers who would soon cut you out. Why not do it yourself if you think it’s such a great money maker?
I don't understand how any of this makes sense given "and you hold patents".
Where does the company mention patents?
That would've been a fair response, but you just kind of ignored that part of the comment you were replying to.
maybe they are saying patents are territorial, and not always respected
If they sell components or monitors then they only have to do one "simple" thing right. If they sell tablets/cellphones/laptops then they have to do a number of more complex stuff well enough that people will consider switching.
Instantly bought this to support your mission
A "calm" computer interface is such a welcome idea and quality pursuit
Participating in the good of the digital world - information access, communication, creativity
While mitigating the bad - always on notifications, bio-hostile blue light interface, doom scrolling etc
I hope that this V1 release of your philosophy is successful enough to keep building
To that end what are your long term goals / plans?
holy moly dude you are articulating our value prop and philosophy even better than we can
glad to be on the same team!
long term goals/plans
- make a whole ecosystem of healthier, distraction free computers.. phones, laptops, monitors, workstations, watches, PDAs, epaper whiteboards, etc - make awesome software that we can offer as public goods, funded by cash flow from hardware and memberships etc - make 'magical analogue objects' like actually good sunrise alarm clocks, time timers, calendars, habit trackers, better phillip hues, etc
Definitely lean into the phrase "calm computer interface"
Access to the same stuff as your phone, but chill about it
Love the idea of informative ambient objects as well—people love the Standby Mode on iPhones, this sounds like that but better
This has been a thing for a little while: https://calmtech.com/
Wow. Great looking device and great long term vision/mission. As someone who hacked an old Kindle to make a persistent weather display, I am wholly in support of what you're working on.
Fantastic! I am definitely going to follow you and team with great interest!
These ideas are SO needed right now.
If you stick with an open source ethos and allow anyone to hack and write software for these things... you're going to find a highly devoted niche of lifetime customers. I am one of them. Great work!
Huge congrats! I've been dreaming of something like this for a while - instant pre-order!
your support means everything! thank you!
i wish people could understand how hard it is to survive low volume novel consumer electronics.. not meant to solicit pity, but to appreciate why we're all just stuck with big tech after indie company after indie company fail
make a display for framework laptop. please
I'd love one of these displays in my MNT Reform too. Another (tiny!) indie tech company :)
I would buy this.
I just bought a Boox Max Lumi 2, but being able to effectively code in a sunny park would be amazing.
Your prices are impressive for low volume.
I hope things go well for you. These are the kinds of devices I want to become mainstream.
boochiboo12,
Please reach out to the team at goodereader.com and see if a review can be arranged. they cover e-ink and several e-ink alternatives, including other vendors in the RLCD space.
FYI: goodereader has a bad reputation in the eink world. Their reviews are fair but their shop is borderline scam.
Thanks for the head's up.
I don't agree.
Some links: https://www.reddit.com/r/ereader/s/ZpVE0dTM98 https://www.reddit.com/r/eink/s/LonNpgGAIF https://www.reddit.com/r/eink/s/YqUXfrZhnm https://www.reddit.com/r/eink/s/xmurkiHGam
Alright.
You are putting together a compelling argument for both skepticism and caution before placing an order for merchandise from the goodereader store. (not something I planned to do)
--
How do you feel about their youtube channel where they review all the various devices in this market segment?
Specifically, have you ever found their reviews to be inaccurate?
Do you know of any alternative source of reviews in this market segment that is as comprehensive or experienced?
One thing I'll say in favor is that they do send their writing staff to the various trade shows.
They specifically said, "their reviews are fair". Maybe you missed that part of their post?
It would be cool if we could cast our phone screens to it. That way we wouldn't have to deal with file and app synchronization, cellular tethering, or any of the other friction points of using multiple devices.
its a good idea, know any good firmware / encoding engineers who could help us build really good casting?
Let's chat. I'd love to connect and see if we can make this happen.
There's a WiFi standard for screen casting. No idea how it works. Support seems spotty, though steadily growing?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracast
I think this might be possible out of the box with Android apps like ScreenStream: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=info.dvkr.scre...
That seems to go in the other direction, show Android screen on browser.
What is the reason it isn't worth your while to sell the display seperately so other devices can be built using it?
Much lower margin if you just sell a component.
Still, once their display partner is ramped up, lower margin is still margin. Get it out there through Waveshare or someone similar.
I have purchased and made use of several raw displays from them. All, but the big e-ink one have been great to work with. That one has some proprietary interface to unlock the real speed potential and individuals cannot sign the NDA. Grrr..
It's not that hard to start a company on paper.
They are trying to sell an entire ethos as well. But also what the other person said.
Any plans to sell just the display?
It's interesting that Anjan compared the display tech to Pebble, because selling off the company instead of just the IP is where Pebble completely failed consumers. Pebble had something incredibly special, and then Fitbit bought Pebble and (for reasons I don't know) immediately killed all their projects and shelved all their tech. In a different reality, Anjan would have said, "Think of it as a Godzilla sized Fitbit watch with a decade of improvement". Selling just the screens seems like the obvious play here
The Pebbles display wasn't Pebbles own tech, they used off-the-shelf MIP LCDs from Sharp. You can still buy them and they're still used in more utilitarian wearables, e.g. from Garmin, and in the Playdate.
Sharp doesn't make anything tablet-sized though, so that's not what OP is using.
They do have 5" and 31.5" reflective displays though, they call them Reflective IGZO Displays.
https://github.com/Modos-Labs/Glider if you're interested in DIY see here
Will I be able to install LineageOS on this - as I do on all of my devices ?
yes! we're going to come out with a bootloader unlock tool as well so you can do whatever you want
our goal is to be DIY friendly, so we included things i've always wanted in a tablet like:
- microSD card expandable - pogo pins for custom accessories (ie cyber deck FTW) - 2 extra physical buttons you can custom map
I’ll buy one when I see this materialize.
I'm buying one now, believing in good faith that this will in fact materialize. GP, please follow through! :-D
Oooh nice ! You have one more customer
I'm really thinking about buying one, but I NEED someone (even paid sponsors) on YT to review it and post a real-life video demo of them using it for a real thing in their office to believe the claims.
I can really see how this will make meetings, 1:1s, reviews, blogging, and designs at work way WAY more deep and engaging than with my MacBook. And perhaps it'll help me get into reading more, as well!
I think a nice demo can be Duolingo on it - it's something I do everyday so moving to this device could help me in that :)
Unsure how you are intending to use it for 1:1s and meetings--I don't believe this has a camera, so it can't be your primary device you are taking the call on. Of course, as a note-taking device during a meeting, this would shine! :)
They probably meant meeting in person with this tablet instead of a laptop.
And taking notes during the meeting. Maybe even demo something.
My thought process is: 1. During a physical meeting (all my team is co-located so it's easier) - note taking, brainstorming, etc. If I need to upload something from the meeting to our shared Canvas (on Slack) or to my notes (on Logseq) or just file them away (on Confluence, Logseq, Hibob, Slack, email) - seems a lot easier to stay connected and focused on the precious 1:1 time and juggle the data later. 2. During any other meeting; connect from my laptop via Zoom and write down notes on the paper. This will almost force me to not do what I usually do, which is lose focus on the meeting, stop thinking, and idly do something else (like zeroing my inbox, reading Slack, or programming). When I was in the Army and carried a physical paper notebook every meeting was actually useful for me.
How's the battery usage? You mentioned that it's not bistable and doesn't retain an image on power-off; does that mean the display requires non-trivial power even while displaying a static image? One of the big selling points of my reMarkable 2 is the incredible battery life.
Any plans for color? I know it'd be a sacrifice of brightness. I'm still interested despite the limitations.
These types of displays use power to change the pixels, but almost nothing to retain the existing image, so battery life will be wildly variable depending on how you're using it. Browsing the web with nonstop animations versus reading a book will probably show massive swings in battery life.
This isn’t e-ink, it’s a transflective LCD so that’s not true here
It's not e-ink, but it appears to be the same as Sharps "memory" display, which means it continues to show an image even after power is removed. They have extremely low power draw when displaying static pixels
I was looking for the battery life to.
after a bit of digging through their page - 8000mAh battery giving "days" of charge.
So a long way from eink insanity, but a usable device in return. Im sure it will do well.
Is it possible for end users to deploy their own operating systems and software?
And do you make it easy for them to do so?
One of my pet peeves about the Android ecosystem is Google's abusive licensing restrictions for their extended service stack prohibiting vendors from distributing their own forks of the base software.
This is the sort of device that I'd be interested in from the hardware perspective, but would not even consider if it's not possible to strip every last remnant of Google from it.
I bet you could get pretty far with Universal Android Debloater: https://github.com/0x192/universal-android-debloater
You can remove just about anything and everything, which is as much a warning as it is a recommendation. Don't use this if you're not ready to reinstall your OS.
Came here to ask this. Depending on the SoC, bringing up Linux via postmarketOS could be pretty easy.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40456834#40460036
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40456834#40458954
The website mentions 60hz, will it also support 120hz?
we're trying to underpromise and overdeliver, and our display can now do 60 - 120 fps, but believe it or not, our PDF renderer and software can't match that yet.
So we're waiting till we can holistically do 120fps before announcing that.
But if you do frame rate tests, you'll see its 120fps
(for the nerds out there, its 6hz-120hz variable refresh rate IGZO)
How is the latency from input to visuals?
For example on an iPad pro 120Hz, it feels really close to actually just moving paper around. Does the Daylight Computer match that input latency?
While we are talking "LCD" and "In direct sunlight" and "display is close to surface" were you able to fit circular polarizers in there, or will I need to take my sunglasses off when using?
This looks very exiting! I am a long-time Sony DPT/Fujitsu Quaderno user and love these kind of devices. My question would be whether you have plans in the future to make a 13.3" version. The 10" versions are just too small for my use (mostly reading scientific papers).
yes we do! ipad mini and 13.Xin versions are kawaii af
Great to hear that! I'll be looking forward to it.
Can we pre-order the 13.X" version?
What's your refund policy if we don't like it? There's no mention of refund/return on the page at all.
Thanks.
full refund if you dont like it
its vulnerable for us as a small startup on a shoestring budget to offer this, but it is the right thing to offer
(sorry we will update the page to add details to refund/return!)
Totally get it and thank you for doing that. I’ve placed an order already.
It’s just there’s also the risk of getting “scammed” by a new startup as well, having it on record would help.
a fellow traveller I see. After getting robbed of over a thousand dollars in different early-product purchases that never materialized, I'm skeptical as well. OP has felt very honest to me, and their tech choices are completely much inline with what I would have done, so I'm inclined to believe them, but the more "in writing" the better.
Your website does its own "improvements" to scrolling, thus on macOS it feels like I'm scrolling through molasses. It's repulsive even. Please, I beg you, just let the platform do its job.
The tablet itself is interesting and impressive. I'm really curious to see that display in action.
The term is “scrolljacking” and yes it’s infuriating.
It's always "Has my device freeze up? Oh no, there seem to be some change happening when I try to scroll, maybe if I scroll more it will work again?"
Any sane browser should let users disable it for all pages.
Any sane browser should also act like <video>, <audio> and <canvas> are unknown tags unless you allow that specific website to use them. Yet somehow, browsers are no longer user agents.
I bought a remarkable. But then a 2 years later had to sell it because my kid was running around and fiddling with my things. I could give my kid the Kindle and will have peace of mind that he can't break, even if he tries. Remarkable is just need a drop on the floor.
How rugged and heavy is your tablet? If it's easily breakable, do you have any future plans to make a tiny, small phone sized light weight paper tablet which one can pull out of pocket like a notepad write stuff and put back, and most importantly have no care in the world of breaking it?
My kid has been using my remarkable 2 for almost 4 years. (Since they were early elementary school aged) It's still fine.
Don't give kids devices if they can't be responsible to take care of them.
Can't tell all this to a very curious toddler.
Why no LTE?
$$$
certifications for mobile/modems are expensive
our future gens will have it once/if we have the resources
The space of android tablets with LTE is frustratingly small.
The product looks very good. However I did NOT like the marketing claim on the front page that points out it is "blue-light free". The claim that blue light is harmful is not really that scientifically proven and if one has blue light at home (awful LED fixtures) this device will happily reflect it, will it not? Please correct me if I'm wrong, I love building light fixtures and 3000K low voltage halogen light, which I believe would work so well with Your device.
Unless the device absorbs the “nocive” part of the spectrum toward ultraviolet, you are correct saying it would reflect it.
I don't think it needs blue light to be harmful for that to be a feature. I personally don't know or care if it's "harmful," but I know that it messes up my sleep cycles so I try to avoid it before bed and especially during the night.
I like my rm2, but 2 of my biggest issues are:
- Syncing changes I make to PDFs to Google drive is tedious
- For some reason there's a restriction of color when drawing on the PDF. Even if The tablet is black and white which is fine, I want to be able to select a wide range of colors since ultimately I'll want to be able to view the PDFs on a legit RGB computer.
What does this workflow look like on Daylight?
I think there’s a limit on colors purely because it’s already nearly impossible to distinguish them on the BW screen?
Yeah but I'll be viewing the PDF on my phone / computer, so being able to annotate in different colors even if the display is BW is important to me.
You should probably eliminate the "blue light free" claim. Per results on clinicaltrials.gov, blue light conclusively does not impact sleep outcomes.
This is complex for a layperson to investigate, but you have to search for insomnia, sleep disorders, wakefulness during the day, and only studies with results. There are many uncompleted studies - it is typical for studies that have no chance of producing an interesting outcome are dropped by their investigators even when registered. However, those uncompleted studies produce many conflating results.
For example, https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT02698800?tab=results specifically investigated using blue light blocking lenses compared to clear lenses. This was not blinded. The differences in all their measures were within 1 standard deviation between the groups, so the result is conclusive that (1) insomnia scores vary very widely among people as a baseline (2) if there is a real effect, it is pretty small and would require a larger sample size to measure. Of course when they measure the part where you don't know if you're looking at blue light, like when you are actually asleep, there is no difference between groups.
This is just to say that the whole blue light thing - placebo effects are real. People perceive this blue light thing as real, particularly tech people. Seed.com is successful. You can do placebos. But you should do the right thing and cut weird claims with no real evidence that are really small brained.
Only 15 people enrolled in the cited study
I know. There are basically no studies that were run to completion. This one was. Go ahead and look for yourself. However, this study proves that if the effect exists, it is pretty small, and probably placebo. Placebo effects are real. But they affect things like surveys. Actual sleep quality did not seem to change.
One problem with reMarkable tablet that I have, is that the stylus' head is not quite completely immovable. It's a bit loose.
Does the stylus for Daylight have the same issue?
It's not supposed to be immovable. The nibs are made of felt, and if they didn't rotate they would wear unevenly and therefore the stylus would give erroneous pressure readings.
I don't mind manually rotating them. But the loose fit makes it hard to do precise calligraphy.
What if I want this display tech but just as a monitor to use with my existing setup for doing engineering work? (E.g. emacs, tiling window manager, etc.)
The device as it's presented looks like a consumption device ("tablet" etc), but tech like this seems like it'd be most useful for a production device (general purpose computing device, programming/development tools).
I'd like the display, but uncoupled from the lifestyle assumptions that come with a consumer lifestyle tablet accessory...
There are a few techniques for using an Android device as a second monitor. I assume those would also work for the Daylight Computer.
Keep an eye on the market for RLCD monitors. I read Hanspree are releasing one ~Sept.
Did you build the display yourself.
This was also my question, and I found what seems to be the answer. It's not quite definitive enough for me, but it's the best I've found so far.
yes
Looks great, albeit a high price point. Why not a newer Android?
just small dev team, updating to new android and porting over all your changes is a tremendous amount of work believe it or not
if launch goes well, the team's gonna get a lot bigger and you can expect us being able to do much more on the AOSP/android side
I did order one, but what happens if you go out of business? What risk do I then have?
I assume this supports the play store, right?
So this is a trans-reflective LCD screen?
Does it invert the colors when backlit?
It's about 50% heavier than rM2; the battery is almost triple the capacity of rM2; I assume these are related and both due to the use of LCD over eInk?
How many shades of gray?
Source: I was the chief hw engineer for this device.
The colors do not invert when the backlight is on, which is great because you can turn on only a slight amount of backlight if you need it, and have it blend to the ambient lighting.
It supports 256 levels of grayscale.
The large battery also helps it last longer and accounts for the much more powerful chip compared to the remarkable
oof. would pay maybe $300 for this, better luck next time
You can't buy regular tablet with this hardware for $300.
This has the same CPU and twice the RAM and storage for $220:
https://www.amazon.com/CUBOT-Tablet-10-4-inch-Android13-Tabl...
So that's a $500 premium for the new display and less RAM and storage.
Could you add a GPS bluetooth to it? Looking for a way to replace paper maps...
Ooh, that's a damn good idea. I used paper maps for years into the digital availability because I like being able to trace paths, draw, highlight things, and annotate them with info.
This would be a killer feature to me, though admittedly is quite niche. If the hardware gets a GPS, the app can be taken care of :-)
You mentioned RLCDs does this mean the screen technology is in the same family as transflective screens?
I have a OLPC and a Toshiba R500 which have this kind of screen and they sorta kinda do work in sunlight but less so now than the newer super bright iPad screens.
I’m curious if you think you have this down if that means there is a road to color in the future.
Came here to ask the same question. The OLPC Screen's "transflective" mode was absolutely amazing when it came out EIGHTEEN years ago in 2006.
I mourn that the tech was never commercialized and that some company is sitting on the patents.
I think it's time to boot the little computer that could, see what the latest distro is for it, and turn it into an E-Reader.
If it doesn't run linux, its not a computer.
It runs Android (which uses linux).
Steelmanning though, I imagine you are saying somethign like "if I can't load my own linux distribution on it, then it's not a computer" then I very much agree. OP has said elsewhere in the thread that they will provide bootloader unlocking and you can put LineageOS or whatever you want on it! For me that was the last thing I needed to get me to buy.
I watched the videos here: https://daylightco.gorgias.help/en-US#article-509983
But it looks like it suffers from backlight bleeding if the screen brightness is at medium or full. I'm a bit concerned about that, can you help explain why that is happening.
those videos were shot on pre-production units. we may still not be perfect, but it should be a lot better on our most recent / PVT / production units
we'll update the videos once launch calms down!
For me the main benefit of EInk, besides the daylight viewing, is battery life. How does your epaper compare to EInk or an iPad? I realize it wont be as efficient, running at 60fps, but I'm curious if it's that much better than a regular tablet display.
E-Ink is definitely not efficient for "animation". It does not consume power in static context being bistable, but switching dot state is very costly. So it all depends on the proportion "static:updating".
FYI there's a typo on the product page, "blacklight" instead of "backlight". I assume that's not a branding thing since it's referred to as a backlight elsewhere.
That could be a great feature. You can use your tablet to find cat pee and other undesirables on your carpet, or just set the mood for a party
I would love to see terminal/unix being part of the story. I realize that one can install Termux, but telling the story without it would be super attractive for developers. It would also further differentiate from iPad.
Any thoughts on this for us developers?
GP has said elsewhere that they are going to provide bootloader unlocking, so alternative OSes should be possible.
What connectivity will it have? Specifically asking about iCloud and Dropbox...
It sounds like it can run any Android app, so Dropbox should definitely work.
Could you please answer my question? Here, without typing it again:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40459804
it's not eink
Can you use VS Code on it? Presumably using a remote back end like github codespaces?
Yes and you could use vscode.dev to edit local files as well
Source: (I have been doing it all along on the daylight during development)
Does this device have a locked bootloader?
Edit: I just saw your other comment that "you will release tools to unlock the bootloader". What is the timeline for that? Can you do it today?
:-D
I like your style! What's involved in such a thing? Since I bailed from Windows Phone 6.5 (after Microsoft broke every promise and turned my expensive and capable hardware into a paper weight by shutting down the store and not upgrading us to WP7 like they promised, but I digress) I've always bought Nexus, OnePlus, or Pixel devices where bootloader is easily unlockable. I did try the Moto X developer edition back in the day which required me to use their website to get an unlock key (still sad that Moto retreated on the openness/unlockability. It could have been a great long relationship Moto).
So, how complicated is a tool to unlock the bootloader?
Why is there zero information about your company on the website? Especially given you want people to give you nearly a grand for something that hasn't even entered production yet?
"About us: A more caring computer company"? Are you serious? Stop trying to be "cute." Even in you HN comment you don't tell us your name. What's with all the secrecy?
It's in the profile.
RLCD, so the screen itself is transparent? If it were rendering an image, and a spotlight shown through it, would it project the image effectively?
I've had some silly little art projects that I'd love to try this screen for, if you have any spares/prototypes or anything you wouldn't mind selling or sharing!
What you're describing exists already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projection_panel. You can find plenty on eBay.
No, because shining a spotlight through it wouldn't result in an in-focus image. Draw something on some transparent plastic wrap and shine a light through it and observe what occurs.
Is there a video of someone playing Doom?
... or Crysis
Hey congrats!!
This is super interesting.
What is the difference between Daylight and e.g. Supernote or Scribe? So any of the currently available e-ink notepads?
You said it’s e-paper not e-ink but what’s the practical difference? Does it still feel like writing on paper or less so?
What kind of pen can I use with it? LAMY Pom is ok for example?
Question: what sets this apart from say, boox? And in comparison, it seems a battery life of days feels a bit low - is that just a conservative estimate? Is that days with all-day use?
Note: I have literally nothing to do with boox other than being a relatively happy customer, even if I do wonder about how much spyware is in their firmware. On that note - is there any guarantees around software updates? The good and the bad of android is the constant updates. Looks like this is on 13 which is soon to be two releases back - are there plans to support future major revisions or is 13 all this is getting?
Is the source available? Is it locked, or can we use our own firmware?
Hi just a minor nitpick - I've used devices like this, and one major complaint about them is that the tips of the Wacom styluses are incredibly fragile (about as bad as pencil lead).
It has been a recurring issue for me that they got damaged while traveling with no way to easily replace them.
If you could engineer a way to protect them (like a proper cap or a clicky pen mechanism) that would be a very handy improvement.
Really cool product! I want this for the display on a fully-featured laptop, not a reader. I want to code in the sun. All I want is a sweet sweet terminal and IDE. Is that on the roadmap?
How hard will it be to scale up resolution/dpi with your tech?
Hopefully you’ll be successful enough to make more devices. Just curious if there is a path to “retina” displays.
Can it be rooted and boot unlocked?
Concerned a little bit about the lower DPI (190), how does aliasing compare to lets say Remarkable 2 (224). I find the Kindle Scribe is at 300 DPI.
Handwriting with the Scribe is amazing to me, hoping to see or understand how it compares.
Instant buy. Love the design and mission. Where can I get the wooden stand?
Wish you the best with your release.
I hope you release smaller and separate display modules too, so that they can be added to a laptop/phone case... Especially since a lot of new phones these days support USB C display port..
Also would be nice to see the pebble watch resurrected..
I'm not sure if it's mentioned on the site, but one thing I'd really love to see that could well nudge this into the "buy" category for me is some focus on repairability - I'd very much like to be able to swap the screen, battery, board, etc. in case the worst happens, rather than having to junk the whole device.
Congratulations! This looks awesome! Very excited to get my hands on one!
This is very cool. I've been waiting for something like this for a while. Since it's so new, are you allowing any hackability like ReMarkable? I'd like to use it instead of Amazon Scribe and integrate against it but $729 is bit steep if it relies on an external service or something.
Oh, since it's Android under the hood, I see that kindle just works?
how's the battery life?
This sounds great, I would love to buy one!
Is there a static specs page? The site seems to have been hugged to near-death but even if not it would be great to know the basics not in a video form: size, weight, OS (e.g., can I run my favorite FB2 reader on it), interfaces, etc.
I am totally willing to lean forward and buy one, but from the current state of the site I cannot even figure out if the screen is 4" or 9" or something in between.
I was ready to enter my credit card number but there's no shipping to Japan.
Do you know - and can share - how this compares vs the Onyx Boox Tab Ultra C Pro?
I guess it might be a very competitive alternative to your product, yet it can't reach 60+fps and is sketchy in terms of security, imho.
Can you please have whomever is looking after your site test it on mobile in dark mode.
It's almost completely unreadable for me. Dark grey text on dark grey background. Light grey text on warm white.
Device: Pixel 7 Pro, dark mode
Browser: Firefox Mobile.
Looks awesome! Can you use it with third-party external keyboards? Bluetooth or USB-C?
What is the expected useful lifespan of such a display? I mean, how long will it last with at least 50 fps and no dead "pixels"?
What’s the chance of a color version of this product coming out anytime soon?
What is the autonomy? How many hours of "normal" use should we expect?
Give it to me with a Linux-compatible chip/board and I am there. This is the display of the solar-powered off grid computer, and succeeding generations will be incredible. And oh yeah, make a phone. With your distraction-free OS.
I'm glad to see so much interest in devices like this. I hope they succeed. I own an Onyx Boox Tab Ultra, which I've been enjoying tremendously, and specs seem to compare favorably to this.
https://shop.boox.com/products/tab
Doesn't seem to be for sale at the moment, but the version with a color epaper layer is: https://www.amazon.com/BOOX-Tab-Ultra-Pro-Digital/dp/B0CHM54...
Do you have more details on your display technology and how it performs? Any demo videos? It sounds like this is the key selling point?
I'd also be curious to see more on the software side of this product - stock android isn't perfect for an eiknk display.
First, this looks amazing, congrats! The primary reason I've held off on buying an eink tablet (remarkable/kindle scribe) is because much of the non-leisure reading I do for work requires enterprise-friendly features like MDM and encryption, and even with that plugging into a laptop to sync every document is a major UX hurdle.
Are you thinking about this primarily as a consumer device with, or do you want to go after those business applications sooner than later?
Disclosure: I work at AWS, own a Kindle Oasis, but have nothing to do with Kindle or devices.
Let me second some other comments here - I would absolutely buy a 24“ display right away. Ideally a colored version. The available options (like Sun Vision) seem sketchy at best, eg their UK rep reached out to me and never responded back - no way I‘d pay them this much without ever seeing the display first.
Please make a version that has the bezel blend in with the screen. It will make it look much more clean and more modern. The remarkable's thin body and bezels are key to why it is so desirable.
Lovely product you have there! I have a love hate relationship with my Remarkable, the distraction free UI fits my brain well, but their complete lack of an API makes it miss the mark of becoming my productivity driver by a light year. Basing your product on Android, I fear the pure distraction free selling point is at risk? How do you see the ecosystem around the device as it mature? And also, obviously, are you emulating the cloud approach that Remarkable has taken, and if so, will there be an API for me to slip my autogenerated daily schedule on to it? :)
If I may indulge in some silly OCD feedback: the hero animation with pages turning has the shadow on the top right line up with the corner, which makes it as if the device has an inset chamfered bezel, which I feel is of disservice to the device. That tripped me up hard until I looked at the other side where the shadow is hitting halfway.
Anyway, congratulations! I both hope you succeed and that it helps drag the 60Hz eink needle forward across the industry.
Will you offer a 13 inch version?
What about computer screens?
And a color version?
For background I have a boox max, a dasung 253 bw and dasung color 253. Happy to spend even more money on a new generation of devices.
Hi, I'm a huge fan of the Supernote. I bought it over the Remarkable based on the pdf reading/annotating capabilities, but I think this can be much much better (especially in the age of AI). Do you have any videos or content on the pdf reader for Daylight?
This is brilliant. Assuming successful revenue stream, are there going to be any further developments?
I would love this as a monitor for coding (I use a plain black on white scheme in vim), for writing and for reading.
Looks like a fantastic device. Any chance of getting these to Australia? I can’t see a shipping option.
Very impressive. Can I use it as an external display? I assume not, but that would strongly push me towards buying one.
Can you make a 60fps paper monitor? I want to have a giant ones of those setup on my desk as a Xerox Alto-style display for my terminal sessions.
Very cool. Been hoping for something like this. Also check out https://www.modos.tech/
I already have Nova Air C, and a color Bigme tablet. I don't think any of the two was more expensive.
The ePaper response time is tempting. But no color over "back"light temperature or no color support would be a step back.
I fondly remember the best smartwatch I ever had - the Pebble Time, and its 60FPS color display. Can we get a version like this too?
Try to change my mind that I need it.
Hey there, congrats! I was really looking forward to a tablet made this way.
Two Qs: 1) is the refresh rate locked at 60 fps? Or does it vary between 60 and 120? This is a big deal for me, as I suffer eye strain from low refresh rate displays 2) Why does it cost 'so much'? I mean, what's included in the 729$?
Congratulations on the new tech, looks impressive! Any plans of developing monitors or portable displays to use with a laptop/smartphone in the sunlight?
Is there a description somewhere of the actual tech?What's the reason you were able to invent fast-refresh e-ink-like displays when no one else could for over two decades?
Given it has a matte finish for writing, which is super cool, but what about wear and tear?
Writing tactility is provided by friction from the matte surface, wouldn't this wear down or scratch over time? If so is the front "glass" bonded to the display, can it be replaced or refurbished?
Super freaking cool tho, was a sad day when pebble died (sharp MiP display) and I've always wanted to play with epaper some more, such a shame eink basically tried to corner the industry for so long. Do you ever intend to sell display modules using this tech for makers and the like?
Can you post a photo or video of a side-by-side comparison of the Remarkable 2 and the Daylight Computer?
Right now it’s hard to actually tell from your marketing materials what the screen looks like
Respect. Not easy to do hardware. I will order one for sure to try it out. Very interesting.
A few questions that i hope to get an answer to:
How did you finance the company? How much money did you spend on R&D & production etc?
What was the initial idea you had? What were the biggest challenges before you knew for sure you got the final product?
I pre-ordered! Huge fan and have been checking it out for a while.
My biggest question and use case is about handwritten notes. Like other paper tablets (Supernote, box, remarkable, etc) have custom drawing/writing apps that sync.
I understand y'all have a fancy custom Android OS, but can I expect to see my notes on other devices, and does it have cool features like handwriting to text auto translation, etc?
I'm very excited! I hope I get my daylight soon.
Please publish a clearer complete spec sheet.
I'm so rooting for you! Got in on Batch 2
When can we expect our favourite tech vloggers to share their thoughts on review units?
Will there be any additional cost like a subscription to use the features of the device?
Congrats on the launch! The tablet is what I've been looking for. Any plan to develop a laptop? I'll readily dump my MBP for it.
What are the physical dimensions?
I've been impressed with the Kindle Scribe I recently got. The drawing and note taking is really nice. However, you have to email yourself PDFs to get the information out of the tablet!
Will we be able to get data off the tablet easily? Will there be documented APIs or other automation available?
Blue light free. Does this mean the design is compromised or is it just irrelevant to an eReader?
I'm surprised by this and it sort of came out of nowhere, how'd you all beat Amazon and other big tech to the market?
The only thing that gives me pause is the android os, which makes me uncomfortable for privacy reasons
With Amazon likely releasing a Kindle Color soon, do you think your tablet will offer color any time soonish?
I tried to order - looks like you're not shipping to Australia? Any plans there?
Would love one - but I was recently burned by an expensive Android e-ink tablet with janky software and meh hardware. I need to be able to touch and play with one before I'd even consider buying it. I hope you make it into retail stores.
Any chance you'll make a laptop with this display in the future? Coding in the sun is a wet dream of mine..
I'd like to put a custom OS on it. Will that be possible? Most tablets have the bootloader locked out by default, and that cannot quench my thirst for Linux.
This is amazing. Congrats.
Question: am I understanding it right that the only potential downside is color accuracy might be off but you get all the other benefits as stated?
(If so, that seems like a great compromise and net better)
It does look great.
Any plans of supplying the ePaper display to OEM's like Amazon, Remarkable, etc.?
Can you make a screen to replace the one from Gameboy using your technology?
How is the Android experience stacking up?
I might actually be in a market for something like this, as I recently cracked my old Boox ... but as I did use few e-ink devices, there was often problem with running Google Play.
I do understand the need for customizing the shell, even with fast fremerate, it still is a Black/White device, but that often means sacrifices had to be made in the accessibility to the rest of the ecosystem and I am not really in the mood to side-load apps :D
This is so cool! Now, I didn't notice anything about waterproofing on your website.
Any plans to come out with a version I don't have to worry about getting wet?
Just clicked on Order and Checkout, but looks like there's no shipping option to Israel. Any update on when that will be possible?
How hard would it be to have a colour screen?
The webpage seems to be broken on Firefox Android.
As soon as the user clicks the burger menu and then dismisses it, scrolling is non functional.
Otherwise congratulations on the launch.
Any chance a 3rd party OS can be flashed?
Your website crashes android Firefox after a few seconds
Since you make it in Japan, can you sell it to me in JPY? Trying to buy anything in $ these days hurts my wallet xD
Congratulations on the launch, what was your hardware journey like. Did you have a hard time raising capital to manufacure prototypes.
I'm working on a small hobbyist project right now,and actually getting it built hasn't been fun.
Would love to hear your advice.
why not a developer version so people can get Linux on it and you will have the true eink tablet killer?
do you plan to monetize on customer lock in (only reason amazon and google don't open their android forks)? or fear of tech being stolen by having drivers open?
Hey there boochiboo12, I have been waiting for a product like this being a long time kindle user and E-Ink enjoyer. So ofc I have been waiting for a product like this for a while. I went through the website and tried to order it but seems like this isn't available for sale in India. Any idea when it will be available here for sale?