I used to work in a genetics lab, and had to prepare trays of gel to visualise DNA tests (PCR testing to identify HLA alleles: effectively like finding someone's blood type, but for their immune system).
The compound in the gel that attaches itself to the DNA particles and makes it so we can visualise the results by UV fluorescence is Ethidium Bromide [1], one of the lower state Bromine salts the article mentions.
The way the electrophoresis gels are (were, by me and the other workers) prepared is by... microwaving a flask with it in. Repeatedly taking it out as it gets hotter to mix it. Usually involving some release of steam. Which includes a small amount of the bromide. Fine in small doses, but when you do it multiple times a day, 5 days a week, 45 weeks of the year...
To this day I wonder how much of an effect it's going to have on me and my colleagues at the time.
My PhD supervisor would wash his teeth over the sink where we'd rinse all the gel preparation tools. He got throat cancer in his 50s and died soon after my PhD defense.
Ethidium bromide is actually surprisingly not mutagenic
https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/myth-ethidium-brom...
This seems very surprising for a molecule that intercalates DNA!
Well there is a cell membrane to negotiate with before reaching the dna.
And a nuclear membrane in eukaryotes as well.
So, are you suggesting that the gel was the cause of the cancer for the supervisor? If so, was that sink’s drain connected to a diverter such that the waste didn’t enter the typical sewage system?
If you have to ask, I think you already know the answer
I don't want to hear any of these stories, considering I am a very clumsy person AND considering that I synthesized polycyclic aromatics. Thank god I got out after a couple of years, but sometimes I wonder what is still floating around in my DNA...
- "attaches itself to the DNA particles"
This is why it's a known mutagen with a long list of very specific, strident toxicity warnings. That's the organic cation, though; compared to that, the Br- anion is utterly benign. You're looking at the wrong hazard!
Br- is a standard counterion in human-approved drugs (those formulated as HBr salts).
https://www.google.com/search?q=hydrobromide+site:drugbank.c...
Apologies, I was writing this while balancing my son on one arm and mixed up some simplification with good old-fashioned mistakes!
I'll nip this in the bud and say "DNA particles" was definitely the wrong word.
You are correct, the Bromine here isn't really the problem; the fact that any intercalculation with DNA occurs is the main problem. Is it Bromine's fault? Not particularly, but it's an accessory in this instance. Based on anecdotal evidence it's common to the electrophoresis process.
My reason for bringing this up is just one of those relatable stories (/s) about why I also don't like working with Bromine (even if contextually it's not Bromine's fault, we love you Bromine!)
I assume you meant intercalation[1], right?
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercalation_(biochemistry)
Twice in one day, this is terrible! I wish these were my only mistakes today, and thank you for the catch and correction!
Bromide ion is in fact essential to animal (including human) life. It's necessary in trace amounts for the production of a weird S=N double bond in collagen IV, in a process where it is briefly converted to the BrO- ion (the +1 oxidation state). This was only discovered fairly recently; getting a fruit fly diet sufficiently depleted in bromide for the deficiency to show up was difficult.
Sea salt should have a fair amount of bromide in it. Bromine can be produced commercially by bubbling chlorine gas through sea water.
Add the EtBr after you microwave the agarose
And cover the flask with some shrink wrap (maybe with a tiny hole punched into it) to hinder steam release.
I actually miss the stretchy shrink wrap, it was pretty useful in daily lab life
Parafilm? 100% agreed. I’ve thought about buying a roll, which will probably last me for a lifetime. One of these days, maybe.
Yeah, that is always an option. However once boiling hot, if you introduce something into the flask it's more likely to create an explosion front. A bit like when someone supercools a bottle of water and then taps it to make it freeze; except with exploding sticky gel, and it's as hot as lava*
*Not actually as hot as lava, but wow does it feel like it
I also had to prepare agarose gels with EtBr in the past, but now there are several alternatives for gel staining, such as SYBR Green.
Luckily I've been out of that particular game for a few years, but it's good to know that less questionable options are available
Which is able to stain because it intercalates into DNA. The same reason why etbr is seen as mutagenic by some.
The author actually has an article on that specific compound. https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/myth-ethidium-brom...
Not saying chronic exposure can never have adverse effects